6 ms·
Slightly tangential, but I want to point out that there's a way forward without pesticides and without economic disaster: We can switch to a "horticultural" mod
by carapace 7y ago
Slightly tangential, but I want to point out that there's a way forward without pesticides and without economic disaster: We can switch to a "horticultural" mode of civilization. The idea is that we use applied ecology to create curated ecosystems that have a high proportion of plants that are agriculturally productive. (Not to be mysterious, I'm talking about Permaculture et. al. but that term seems to upset a few people so I just say "applied ecology" now.) "Food forest" is a search term to try..
Here's a talk "Redesigning Civilization with Permaculture" by Toby Hemenway (RIP) where he talks about how we got into this mess and how we might get out.
http://tobyhemenway.com/videos/redesigning-civilization-with-permaculture/ http://tobyhemenway.com/videos/redesigning-civilization-with...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6b7zJ-hx_c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6b7zJ-hx_c
- acconrad 7y agoRegenerative agriculture is another means with which to restore the land without pesticides or herbicides, with the additional benefit of sequestering nitrogen.
- avip 7y ago>Regenerative agricultural practices include: no tillage diverse cover crops in-farm fertility (no external nutrients) no pesticides or synthetic fertilizers multiple crop rotations https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/food/regenerative-agriculture https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/food/regenerative-agricul... In other words, Regenerative agricultural is indistinguishable from Permaculture as a cultivation method.
- carapace 7y agoAnother reason why I tend to use the phrase "applied ecology" rather than Permaculture. I'm sure if we tried we could find ways to distinguish between what various people mean when they talk about "regenerative agriculture" or "Permaculture", but would it be a profitable use of our time?
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoI absolutely agree. Murray Bookchin did a lot of writing and activism about how to operate societies in an ecologically compatible way that also maximize freedom. See some of his writing on the subject here: http://dwardmac.pitzer.edu/anarchist_archives/bookchin/libmuni.html http://dwardmac.pitzer.edu/anarchist_archives/bookchin/libmu...
- whenanother 7y agothe agriculture shills keep pushing this notion that their way of growing with chemicals is the the most productive way when I've yet to see a study that indicates that any of what they've done has increased crop yields.
- whatshisface 7y agoIf farmers couldn't increase yields they wouldn't buy all of that expensive chemical stuff. If you could farm without buying chemicals or reducing yields, you should go out and do it, you would put everyone else out of business and make a killing.
- matt_kantor 7y agoThe article claims this at the end: > Farms using neonics had 10 times the insect pressure and half the profits compared to those who use regenerative farming methods instead of insecticides according a 2018 study. Like agroecological farming, regenerative agricultural uses cover crops, no-till and other methods to increase on-farm biodiversity and soil health. The regenerative corn-soy operations in the study didn’t have to worry about insect problems, said co-author Jonathan Lundgren, an agroecologist and Director of the ECDYSIS Foundation. > Farmers who are dependent on chemicals are going out of business, said Lundgren, who is also a grain farmer in South Dakota. “It’s painful to see when we have tested, scientifically sound solutions. Working with nature is a good business decision,” he says. It links to this study as a source: https://peerj.com/articles/4428/ https://peerj.com/articles/4428/
- gravelc 7y agoQuoting the abstract: >Regenerative fields had 29% lower grain production but 78% higher profits over traditional corn production systems. Lower yield and much more expensive for consumers is a difficult sell IMO. There's some comments here on this study: http://csanr.wsu.edu/regen-ag-solid-principles-extraordinary-claims/ http://csanr.wsu.edu/regen-ag-solid-principles-extraordinary...
- watertom 7y agoThis would require people to think and be responsible, so it will never happen.
- creddit 7y agoWhen your attitude is one so absolutist, arrogant, defeatist and cynical, that's true.
- Applejinx 7y agoYou're assuming it will be left to market dynamics. I don't think that's a given.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoGovernments are required to remediate market inefficiencies in my view. Sometimes we need some good old central planning. People love to shit on China (me included), but they've got some very good agricultural strategies that I believe wouldn't have ever come out of the free market.
- dang 7y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- mindfulhack 7y agoI never thought I'd read a permaculture comment on HN. I love this community. I was in organic farming for a while, and I get that it's economically more expensive, but the fact that this is a problem is a cultural construct - it's only a 'problem' if people choose to pay more towards disposable electronics and movies at the cinema instead of good, quality, environmentally-friendly food. I think that big chemical agribusiness like Monsanto have bought and paid scientists, abusing the mechanism of scientific study simply to use it as a giant advertising and regulatory-compliance mechanism. They have bought out some voices in the scientific community, and consequently, fooled many more - via the social mechanism of peer pressure.
- mekoka 7y ago> I never thought I'd read a permaculture comment on HN This is the article that introduced me to permaculture almost 5 years ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9074473 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9074473. There have been others popping in now and then.
- papreclip 7y agoIf I'm remembering correctly from my chemistry lectures, there's an upper limit on how much nitrogen can be fixed "organically", and it's nowhere near enough to support the current world population. It's not only a question of cost. That said, I think a lower global population is desirable for many reasons.
- coagmano 7y agoMy understanding is that organic still uses some fertilizers, pesticides and herbicides. Just that they come from a shorter list of approved products EDIT: Okay, permaculture is stricter, so this doesn't apply
- azernik 7y agoKibbutz Sde Eliyahu in Israel does a lot of this work - they breed (and have started genetically engineering) predators and sterile males for pest insects. This was an offshoot of their older business breeding indoor pollinating bees for greenhouses.
- mirimir 7y agoWe have a chicken tractor :) Keeps the weeds down, and you get eggs.
- Dylanfm 7y agoSo glad to see something from Toby Hemenway recommended on here. He has some other interesting presentations, such as: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_lJf46i9pI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_lJf46i9pI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0nzIMJGuEY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0nzIMJGuEY https://soundcloud.com/permaculturevoices/pvp125-tobyhemenwaypv2 https://soundcloud.com/permaculturevoices/pvp125-tobyhemenwa...
- squish78 7y agoI'm thrilled to see this comment upvoted, and you've said some of my own thoughts much better than I could articulate. This mode of thinking helps me re-orient my life goals around 5-year or 10-year plans based on cultivating my land.