24 ms·
I didn't follow the original discussion, but while I agree with the importance of the "open web" and the relative evilness of "corporate blogging silos", I don'
by bambax 16y ago
I didn't follow the original discussion, but while I agree with the importance of the "open web" and the relative evilness of "corporate blogging silos", I don't quite understand how RSS and HTML are "really different faces of the same thing".
RSS is an open way of discovering new content; it is dead(-ish) because real people don't use it.
I'm aware that there are RSS readers; there even are RSS readers that actually work.
But RSS readers are not what the great majority of people use to discover new content; new content is discovered "socially" on YC or Reddit, etc.
- donohoe 16y agoI was stumped by the "really different faces of the same thing" claim as well in relation to HTML and RSS. While RSS is not dead, and probably wont be for a long long time, I also think it needs to be viewed in perspective. "normal" people (not you and me) don't know what RSS is and for the most-part don't use it (or don't know that they are using it sometimes). Dave has some good insights from time to time, but I get the impression that he is stretching his credits and claims far beyond reality. You can only wave the "I co-invented RSS way back" flag for so long.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- codingthewheel 16y agoI think what he meant by that was that webpages and RSS feeds ultimately boil down to the same thing: transmitting markup across the wire. That's really all an RSS feed usually is; HTML markup CDATA'd or escaped inside a simple XML doc (often incorrectly). Whether you request a webpage through a browser or an RSS feed through a reader, you're essentially doing the same thing. And I think RSS/ATOM have failed to go mainstream for three reasons: - The RSS and Atom specs are a mess. A mess. And have been for years. Most RSS/ATOM feeds are technically incorrect in some way, usually around the escaping of markup and/or the presence of feed metadata. - There have been few, if any, truly inspired RSS readers (Google Reader doesn't count). - Browser makers have never made RSS a first-class user experience. When asked to, the response is "nobody uses RSS". But nobody uses RSS because there's not a compelling RSS facility in any major browser, including Firefox.
- davewiner 16y agoWhere do you see me waving any flags? I think you should be equally protective of open formats and protocols. Stand up for them. That's all I'm doing donahoe.
- Kevin_Marks 16y agoIf you want an HTML equivalent for RSS, there's hAtom: http://microformats.org/wiki/hatom http://microformats.org/wiki/hatom
- davewiner 16y agoThey are different sides of the same thing -- our websites. One is for looking at things in the browser, and the other is for mashups by software, the kind of stuff people in YCombinatorLand are supposed to savvy about. What difference does it make how many people directly use RSS feeds. Systems are built around it that flow the news to people in every context. It's how news is distributed on the net. You guys know all this, but you pretend you don't -- why?