5 ms·
Agreee, although I think the arguments and calculations in that thread are a bit silly. If you take any finite distribution of fixed charges, and you fire a tes
by amluto 7y ago
Agreee, although I think the arguments and calculations in that thread are a bit silly. If you take any finite distribution of fixed charges, and you fire a test particle from infinity at the charge distribution, one of two things happens: either it hits one of the charges, or it goes back out to infinity, possibly in a different direction, with the same velocity it started with. The idealized field distribution that accelerates everything going through does not exist in electrostatics.
So either some time-varying fields are needed or interactions between space plasma particles is needed.
Also, the efficiency calculation doesn’t account for particles hitting the grids and thus creating a short-circuit current. Which has its own issue: in the original paper, 500W is going somewhere, but there is no explanation of how, exactly, any current flows in the circuit, which is inconsistent with any power at all being used.
- doubleunplussed 7y agoThat doesn't sound right to me. Imagine I have a proton and an anti proton, and I fire the proton at the anti proton along a perfect straight line. Classically, and ignoring nuclear forces, the proton will end up stationary and the anti proton will instead be launched away, just like a direct collision between pool balls leaving the cue ball stationary.
- jbay808 7y agoGP was referring to a distribution of "fixed charges", so it's not possible to transfer momentum to them.
- doubleunplussed 7y agoWell a spacecraft is not fixed, you can push it around, which is the whole point of a reaction drive. An unmovable spacecraft would have to have infinite mass. So the assumption does not apply.
- ScottBurson 7y ago> in the original paper, 500W is going somewhere, but there is no explanation of how, exactly, any current flows in the circuit I puzzled over that a bit too. I think the answer is that as protons are shot out the negative side and electrons out the positive side, they create a field that counteracts the field between the grids. Maintaining the field strength thus requires continuously adding charge to the grids. In the hypothetical case of infinite grids (being charged by an infinite number of generators), the areal charge density on the grids would increase without bound, so that the charge density difference, and therefore the field, across the infinite plane halfway between the grids would remain constant. Exactly how this would translate to the finite case I'm less clear on, but I suppose the behavior would be similar, at least shortly after the drive was first turned on. Sooner or later, though, I think the voltage across the gap would increase to the point that any generator you could actually build wouldn't be able to push any more charge onto the grids.
- amluto 7y ago> Maintaining the field strength thus requires continuously adding charge to the grids. I'm not sure what you mean. The whole system is running at steady state. For simplicity, pretend that the spaceship is very massive or is otherwise accelerating at negligible rate so that the spaceship's frame is inertial. [0] In the spaceship's frame, there is some electron current density at all points in space, some proton current density at all points in space, and some distribution of charge carriers on the grids. If we further assume an infinite work function on the grids, then there is no field emission and no plasma charges are captured, so there is no transfer of charge between the plasma and the grids. But then there is no current on the grid, so the driver circuit outputs no power, and the engine can't possibly do any work. So either my analysis is missing something or the paper is wrong. Or both. [0] This could be achieved exactly by firing an equal-but-opposite-thrust conventional rocket in the opposite direction. It doesn't really matter for my argument anyway, I think. [1] Or the grid could be made of metal filaments wrapped in perfect insulators, but then there's an issue of charges building up on the outside of the insulators. In general, the grid will capture some charge from the plasma, and this will be a parasitic loss on the system. I would certainly believe that a pair of solid parallel finite metal plates flying at high speed through a plasma generates a force, but that's not what's being described in the paper.