3 ms·
The author is Robert M. Zubrin. To write it off because the abstract doesn't mention a specific technique seems a bit silly, especially given that Zubrin person
by vidarh 7y ago
The author is Robert M. Zubrin. To write it off because the abstract doesn't mention a specific technique seems a bit silly, especially given that Zubrin personally knows a lot of the people involved in Breakthrough Starshot and surely is aware of it, including its massive caveats.
It's worth noting that the paper specifically discusses the need for methods that are not limited in travel direction, and in that respect Breakthrough Starshot has the same caveats as a solar sail and so treating laser driven propulsion separately is pointless.
Another major difference that is so obvious as to not require a mention of every specific alternative is that it is talking about a propulsion method that avoids the need for us to provide a source of thrust.
Laser driven systems doesn't require the ship to carry propellant, but we're still paying the cost to provide thrust, while this design is basically 'just' relying on there being a source of protons and electrons with a speed differential relative to the current speed and direction of travel of the ship that it can 'scoop up'.
That makes for fundamentally different tradeoffs relative to classical sail based propulsion.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]