3 ms·
That is a very modern reinterpretation. Trade was a practice of more-or-less equals. One doesn't trade with gods, much as one doesn't trade with parents. One ho
by ncmncm 7y ago
That is a very modern reinterpretation. Trade was a practice of more-or-less equals. One doesn't trade with gods, much as one doesn't trade with parents. One hopes to attract their favorable attention, and fears their ire or neglect.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoOr, in older words: "Holy Athena," she cried, "protectress of our city, mighty goddess, break the spear of Diomedes and lay him low before the Scaean gates. Do this, and we will sacrifice twelve heifers that have never yet known the goad, in your temple, if you will have pity upon the town, and on the wives and little ones of the Trojans." Thus she prayed, but Pallas Athena granted not her prayer. (Iliad 6.305-311) Direct offers to trade with the gods are common in classical mythology. (And, um, everywhere else, ancient or modern day, fiction or reality.) And I specified that a sacrifice was often just an offering. Trading is normal, but not required. > much as one doesn't trade with parents I mean, I guess I can agree with this. I take it you don't have kids?
- romaaeterna 7y agoIt was Socrates' atheistic critique of contemporary definitions of piety to call this "trade" or "ἐμπορικὴ" in Euthyphro 14e. And for an historical example, according to Xenophon [Xen. Anab. 3.2.10] the Athenians promised to sacrifice a goat to Artemis for every Persian killed at Marathon. This turned out to be 6,400 [Hdt. 6.117] and since they could not find enough goats, they instituted a yearly sacrifice of 500. Although only a wag like Socrates would call this a direct trade with the goddess.