5 ms·
> now the law says that the packaging must clearly point out if the quantity inside has changed. We need this law in the US. I’m not one to push for new regula
by gnicholas 7y ago
> now the law says that the packaging must clearly point out if the quantity inside has changed.
We need this law in the US. I’m not one to push for new regulations, but I have seen this happen time and again with big companies (Nabisco, General Mills) that shrink their boxes and count on the customer not to notice.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoOn the other hand a lot of candy gets bigger and bigger. I am pretty sure the candy bars and ice cream scoops I got when I was a kid were half of the current size. Or even less.
- dsparkman 7y agoI love to watch the shrinkage of ice cream. Over the past 10 years, the standard packaging of ice cream has gone from 1/2 gallon (1.9 L) to where they are currently at 1.4 L, with prices staying relatively the same.
- gnicholas 7y agoThere’s also the trend toward “whipped” ice cream which has fewer calories and lower COGS because it is mixed with air.
- geodel 7y agoHuh, I see most of the time in US price/oz is mentioned along with price of item. This greatly helps me decide if buying larger package could save me some money with having to do calculation myself, which I would have to do in my country.
- gnicholas 7y agoYes, this is helpful for comparing two items on the shelf next to each other, and it is present in some stores. But there are only a few items that I actually remember the price/oz between visits. Mostly I remember only the price per package (if anything). For example, Triscuits and Wheat Thins are a good buy at $2/pack, and OK at $2.50/pack. But when they shrink the pack, I'm SOL because I have no idea what the price/oz equivalent is. Maybe this is "my fault", but I'd guess that most consumers don't pay that much attention to the exact number of ounces (which are sometimes fractional) in the box.
- unimployed 7y agoI always look for price/weight or price/volume or price/count stickers but many retailers and items only list the price making you do the math. Even then, I’m aware that many items have differences in content which game the price/measurement like a lower ingredient content (less cocoa per measurement and more fillers or water content). There is not really a great way to combat these practices if you are not some kind of professional buyer that only purchases at wholesale scales.
- winter_blue 7y agoYea, this is something that's always impressed me about this US. In other countries, I have to pull up a calculator app on my phone, and calculate the price per kg for various packaging sizes, to figure out which one is the best deal. It's almost as though store labels in the US are designed with the discerning consumer in mind...
- blihp 7y agoDon't be too impressed. We only have the price per unit listings, ingredient lists etc. as the result of bad business practices (and sometimes deaths) in the previous century. So it's not retailers or manufacturers responding to consumer demand... they're responding to government laws and regulation.
- refurb 7y agoAs most regulations are around the world - a response to some problem. It’s not unique to the US. Do you have a source for the $/Oz being due to bad behavior? From what I’ve heard it was done purely to address consumer demand.
- hirsin 7y agoIt's rarely purely price/oz. Often it's mixed units - eg for granola bars or similar you'll see four different items listed at - Price/oz Price/lb Price/bar Price/unit (which might be bar or package of two bars) So you get tk calculate the difference in your head.
- blihp 7y agoTrue enough re: them usually being a response to a problem. See the 'Background' section on page 11 of https://www.nist.gov/document/sp1181-unit-pricing-guidepdf https://www.nist.gov/document/sp1181-unit-pricing-guidepdf and more generally https://www.nist.gov/pml/weights-and-measures/laws-and-regulations/retail-and-unit-pricing-laws https://www.nist.gov/pml/weights-and-measures/laws-and-regul.... So yes, it was done purely to address consumer demand... by way of laws and regulations with producers and retailers under threat of even more onerous laws and regulations. A contemporary example to hopefully convey the situation back then: if 'right to repair' becomes law at some point, this would also be due to consumer demand. Notice the level of interest companies have in addressing this consumer demand prior to legislation being passed...
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> We need this law in the US We'd end up in a miasma of litigation around whether one product is a reduced quantity of another, or if they're separate product lines. Products already list quantities. That's enough for someone paying attention to value.
- dbskdb 7y agoNot composition. I’ll do the math. But I do want wt%
- Osiris 7y agoI always look at the price per ounce instead of the total price of the item to compare.
- mikepurvis 7y agoConsumerist (RIP) used to run a great series called the "grocery shrink ray" where they would call out these changes: https://consumerist.com/tag/shrink-ray/ https://consumerist.com/tag/shrink-ray/
- eyeball 7y agoDamn. I didn’t know consumerist had been wiped out. Bought by consumer reports?
- mikepurvis 7y agoSomething like that: https://consumerist.com/2017/10/30/please-pardon-the-interruption/ https://consumerist.com/2017/10/30/please-pardon-the-interru...
- Spooky23 7y agoOne of the big tuna vendors would shrink rat like 1/16 of an ounce from tuna cans. Just raise the price, nobody is fooled.
- graycat 7y agoThere there are alternatives: (1) Recently I wanted a bag of sugar. At my closest grocery store, the bag was 4 pounds instead of 5. No problem: At my next stop at Sam's Club, I got two bags, 15 pounds each. (2) Sometimes dish soap comes in small bottles. Okay, at Sam's get a gallon jug of their generic dish soap and with a funnel refill the small bottles. Same for glass cleaner, etc. (3) Pizza can be $7 to $20. Okay. (i) In a 5 quart bowl, add 750 ml water and 1 T dry yeast. Let the yeast soften. Measure 1 kg of flour. Add 1 T salt to the water, stir, add 2/3rds of the flour, stir, add the rest of the flour, mix some, and dump on a floured board. By hand mix and knead for 8 minutes. Return to the bowl, cover, and let rise to fill the bowl. Dump on the board, form in a long loaf, cut into 8 equal pieces, place each each in a covered plastic bowl, refrigerate. Starting the next day for two weeks or so, for a pizza, take one of the dough pieces, in a microwave proof plate form in a circle 7-9" in diameter, and warm in microwave for 3 minutes. Add 3 T sauce, 1/4 C shredded Mozzarella, and maybe some pepperoni, sausage, etc., place in a clean steel pan, over medium heat, covered, for 13 minutes, move to a cutting board, slice, slide to a dinner plate, add 1 T of grated hard cheese, and eat. Get the flour, 25 pounds, at Sam's, and then the flour for one pizza is about 9 cents. With good toppings, the total cost is still about $1. So, anytime, in 20 minutes, 7 of effort and 13 waiting, get a pizza faster, better, and cheaper than frozen, carryout, or delivery.
- JackFr 7y ago> So, anytime, in 20 minutes, 7 of effort and 13 waiting, get a pizza faster, better, and cheaper than frozen, carryout, or delivery. I don't know where you live, but in Manhattan your version will be cheaper, but it will definitely not be better and most likely will be no faster. Neither your stove nor your oven can match a commercial pizza oven.
- graycat 7y agoAs I wrote, I don't use an oven! Instead I finish the baking in a covered steel pan, and this does give a crisp bottom. > match a commercial pizza oven. "Match" in what sense? What I described is different but works great. For the 20 minutes, even in Manhattan, tough to take the order, make and bake the pizza, slice it, box it, and deliver it, all in 20 minutes. For the quality, that's a matter of taste, but frozen, carryout, and delivery don't use better ingredients. Whatever strong opinions some people in Manhattan may have about pizza, for the world of pizza, Manhattan is a very tiny place. E.g., apparently all or nearly all Sam's Clubs scattered all across the US sell 5 pound bags of part skim, shredded, Mozzarella cheese, and no doubt nearly all of it goes for pizza: Pizza is all over the US and much of the rest of the world -- in comparison, Manhattan is a small thing! By the way, for delivering a pizza quickly, there is a fundamental problem made fully clear in queuing theory: The orders have to arrive essentially as a Poisson process. But the pizza shop has only fixed capacity in pizzas made per minute. So, we have random demand fed to a fixed resource. Then the pizza shop has just two alternatives, (i) deliver quickly but have a lot of expensive time where the delivery people are doing nothing and (2) delivery slowly, from a queue, where the delivery people are busy but the customers have to wait.
- JackFr 7y ago> We need this law in the US. I’m not one to push for new regulations, but I have seen this happen time and again with big companies (Nabisco, General Mills) that shrink their boxes and count on the customer not to notice. Except for fast-food companies, which we've been told have slyly been increasing their portion sizes and making us fat. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17585324 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17585324 Or maybe we could just stop being victims of the evil corporations and we take responsibility for our lives.
- TomMckenny 7y agoInstead, toilet paper literally says 12=48 and the like.