3 ms·
1000x would make human use ~20% of the earth system, but earth side solar wouldn't get counted twice, so it would be less. I agree that would have an impact, bu
by maxerickson 7y ago
1000x would make human use ~20% of the earth system, but earth side solar wouldn't get counted twice, so it would be less. I agree that would have an impact, but I doubt the other poster was imagining the 1000x scenario.
The numbers are something like 20 terawatts for current human utilization and 100 petawatts for solar power.
- kragen 7y agoYeah, that's about what I calculated in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20426368 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20426368 — 130 petawatts of terrestrial insolation and 18 terawatts of world marketed energy consumption. I think solar panels will tend to have lower albedo than the surfaces they shade (sunlight they reflect is not available for energy production, and even the 16%-efficient ones that are common today are pretty black), especially before the humans start floating them on oceans. Essentially all the energy they successfully harvest will later be converted to heat on Earth. So they will represent a positive thermal forcing in the climate system. I don't know what you mean about getting counted twice? I don't know why anyone would propose orbiting solar panels when it's still easy to put solar panels on deserts. So I assumed that was what they were imagining, even though that's not a long-term scenario; it could happen before 2089, which is very short-term.
- maxerickson 7y agoSolar energy gathered and utilized inside the earth energy system doesn't add energy to the system. So if we were using 5 Petawatts of ground based solar power, we wouldn't be adding much to the overall system. Unless we stored a lot of it and shifted the heat to a different time of year.
- kragen 7y agoOh, I agree that you don't add energy to Earth just by harvesting energy that would have been absorbed and converted to heat. So a solar panel on the ocean doesn't warm up the Earth any, because the ocean is just as black as the panel. But you do add energy to the Earth by harvesting, or merely absorbing, energy that would have been reflected into space. So the same solar panel on the Salar de Uyuni will warm up the Earth. That's what my comments above about albedo are about; I'm not double-counting in the sense you thought. Does that clarify? None of this is significant until solar power generates substantially more power than current world marketed energy consumption, which is to say, for at least a decade or three. Thank you for helping me to explore these issues!