3 ms·
One thing that struck me from the piece (what I could read, before switching to skimming) was the implicit acceptance of the outsized power of Yale people. It
by neilv 7y ago
One thing that struck me from the piece (what I could read, before switching to skimming) was the implicit acceptance of the outsized power of Yale people. It sounded like the concern was that they acknowledge and wield this power well. I didn't see a question of whether they should have this power.
- walshemj 7y agoThat is the take I got to is if the writer feels that there is some golden age in the past that the "elites" should adhere to. And academic politics (which the article mentions) have always been nasty.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoI agree. We should ask if they should have this power and the people should seize it back if necessary.
- Nasrudith 7y agoWell that is the thing - it isn't granted by us or even talent but by the connection to the resources of others and the benefits - not all of them material. Many of them even if they suffered full fledged "flee a homicidal government and start with nothing" would have immaterial assets like education and experience running large organizations to gain wealth and rise up again.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoYou’re right, but all of this flows from perceived status. Status is not immutable. Stanford was not the elite institution it is today in the 1940s for instance.
- lancebeet 7y agoArticles questioning who ought to have power are a lot more common. I found it refreshing that the author left that out to focus on just the issue of what those in power should do. That question may be at least as important, given that those with wealth and power are unlikely to let go of said wealth and power, regardless of what the rest of society may think.
- rossdavidh 7y agoNo doubt they should not, but that would be a different topic, one which has been (and will continue to be) abundantly addressed, in this era and every other. Yet, there is always a ruling class, and their children don't always act this way. So, it is a worthy topic to consider: why this way, and why now? To the question of "why does the ruling elite have so much power?", one could answer, "it was ever thus", which is hardly satisfying but is true. But to the question, "why do the children of the ruling elite pretend they are the oppressed?", such an answer is manifestly untrue. So, there is a question there that needs answering, which doesn't already have centuries of answers written.
- neilv 7y agoI've seen "it was ever thus" serve as a rationalization. I'd have liked to see an acknowledgement of the question of rightness of power; otherwise, I think it just reinforces the default. Even (in so many words): "perhaps it's neither fair nor optimal for society that you have so much power over others, but, given that you do [then all the stuff about responsibility]"
- PunchTornado 7y agotoo bad Yale didn't teach the author that brevity is the soul of communicating.