4 ms·
> The fundamental problem is "player benefits from minimizing risk", which is usually boring. I remember playing the entirety of Doom, and IIRC, Doom II, in a
by teddyh 7y ago
> The fundamental problem is "player benefits from minimizing risk", which is usually boring.
I remember playing the entirety of Doom, and IIRC, Doom II, in a careful, methodical manner, and I never found it “boring”.
- mangamadaiyan 7y agoDitto quake, and quake II, in my case.
- mrec 7y agoSame here. For reasons which now escape me, I decided to play through the whole [1] of Quake II without ever getting hit or otherwise taking damage. I don't remember it making the game easier, just differently difficult. I spent a lot of time reloading. I get very irritated by game designers who decide that I'm just not having the right kind of fun. Enemies spawning right behind me in an area I've just cleared, or infinite spawns, usually trigger an immediate uninstall. The Deus Ex games got this mostly right, mostly. (Those abysmal boss fights being the exception; I gather they were done by a completely different team, and my god it showed.) [1] Right up until the final boss fight, anyway. I think I made an exception for that. I think I swore off consumables like the Quad Damage too, but don't recall the details.
- teddyh 7y ago> I spent a lot of time reloading. Mike, the saveaholic: https://web.archive.org/web/20080106232309/http://archive.gamespy.com/dailyvictim/index.asp?id=166 https://web.archive.org/web/20080106232309/http://archive.ga...
- mrec 7y agoHa! Firstly, that's spot-on. Secondly, you have remarkable powers of recall when it comes to 18-year-old observational humour. In my defence, it was only that one playthrough. Most games I approach more normally (albeit with a sneaky-snipey style wherever possible).
- teddyh 7y ago> you have remarkable powers of recall I’ll tell you my secret. It’s called… <whispers> Bookmarks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15574890#15575460 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15574890#15575460
- mrec 7y agoThat doesn't really help, it just replaces the intimidating powers of recall with equally-intimidating powers of managing twenty years of bookmarks without drowning under them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- teddyh 7y agoI currently have 1324 bookmarks, many of which are obsolete and/or dead. One might reasonably argue that I am drowning under them.
- blattimwind 7y ago> (Those abysmal boss fights being the exception; I gather they were done by a completely different team, and my god it showed.) Those were indeed done by a different studio that was otherwise not integrated into the development at all. The Director's Cut somewhat works around these areas.
- HelloNurse 7y agoIt's called "playing to win". Staying safe behind a chokepoint might be unexciting (usually not boring, given the satisfaction of aiming and hitting and the sense of accomplishment of clearing enemies), but rushing forward and getting shot is on a different level: it's simply a mistake, and players learn to avoid it. Personally, I tend to play Doom cautiously, engaging as few enemies as possible, retiring eagerly, and often running through exposed areas instead of stopping to shoot. Other FPS games, particularly PvP ones require a different approach: if the main challenge is to keep moving to find enemies and ambush them, or to aim and dodge well enough (or better than the opponent) during brief one on one encounters, the "door problem" simply doesn't exist.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Staying safe behind a chokepoint might be unexciting I didn't understand the main solution the article offers. We'll solve the problem that the door is a safe chokepoint by putting another safe chokepoint "inside" the arena, right in front of the door. Now everything is fine, because you have the same gameplay, but you've labeled the floor the player is on "good" instead of "bad". What did I miss? (I also didn't really understand why this was supposed to be a problem in the first place, but I put that down to the fact that I hate the entire genre under discussion. As pointed out elsewhere in the thread, roguelikes can suffer from a similar problem. Angband gets very repetitive: 1. Some monsters appear in groups. At low levels, you need to fight them in a hallway. This is basically fine with me. Later versions made group monsters unwilling to leave rooms, which made them no more dangerous than before, but much, much more tedious. 2. Some monsters can summon other monsters. If you fight one of these in a room, you'll die. The solution is one of two things: 2a: If the monster moves, dig out a corridor and wait for the monster to come to you. With no empty spaces around you, summoning can't do anything. 2b: If the monster doesn't move, use wall removal effects to open a path that allows you to target it with ranged attacks while staying out of its line of sight. In general, it will also be out of your line of sight, so this means memorizing a few common flight patterns for ranged attacks. 3. OK, some monsters can hit to cause earthquakes, opening empty spaces where you were expecting the safety of walls. And some monsters can move through -- and incidentally destroy -- walls, completely wrecking the idea that you might not get surrounded. The answer to this one is to use a Destruction effect to automatically kill summoning wall-destroying monsters as soon as you see them, because even for a maxed out character, they're too dangerous to fight. So the game is about luring uniques into special diagonal-only corridors and grinding it out against them there (Hit! Hit! Hit! Heal! Hit! Hit!), carefully conserving all your healing potions for the fight against Morgoth, who causes earthquakes and summons everything.)