5 ms·
Can someone explain why Red Hat is so valuable? Why would IBM put such a big bet?
by mrtksn 7y ago
Can someone explain why Red Hat is so valuable? Why would IBM put such a big bet?
- _delirium 7y agoThe general strategy seems to be: IBM's customers have been slowly transitioning from proprietary IBM OSs (AIX, z/OS) to Linux for a lot of their workloads, and IBM has accommodated this out of necessity, but wants to retain licensing revenue and some degree of branding/control in that situation by having such customers on an Enterprise IBM Linux. RHEL more or less already owned the Enterprise Linux space, so IBM just bought them instead of developing something in-house. Along with IBM getting an Enterprise Linux brand out of it, they also seem to be hoping some RHEL customers who aren't otherwise IBM customers might be converted to buy more stuff (e.g. maybe some of them can be sold on RHEL/POWER9 servers). (Whether that justifies the valuation I don't know enough to guess on.)
- chr15p 7y agoOther way round, IBM are hoping that a lot of their customers who aren't already big Red Hat customers can be converted to using RHEL and (especially) Openshift. They already have all the sales and delivery relationships in place that they need to do really big (like 100 million to billion dollar big) deals, much bigger then anything Red Hat has been able to sell on their own. They also have relationships to sell RHEL/Openshift to IBM customers that RH struggled to get through the door of. So if they can get big growth in the number and size of Red Hat deals by selling to their existing customers then they can grow RH massively and of course all growth in Red Hat deals is growth in IBMs profits. And if they can sell some of them RHEL on POWER9 they will be very happy to take that money as well :)
- ethbro 7y agoAnd that's also a good defensive move. Given the market is moving, even IBM's major customers would eventually migrate to newer technologies. (On the order of decades) By providing something that mostly satisfies that need, IBM essentially drilled a relief well to take the pressure off. When they're ready to migrate, they could get 80% value of what a non-IBM migration would get them by moving to IBM's product. For a lot of large, slow, conservative orgs, that's good enough.
- chr15p 7y agokinda, I mean, IBM consulting have been happy to move customers off legacy IBM/AIX/DB2 onto Dell kit running Oracle on windows for decades now if thats what the customer wanted and was prepared to pay, precisely because its better to take the services revenue and the reseller margin then lose everything. So that relief well was drilled years ago, and certainly the name IBM helped with persuading those slow conservative orgs to use their services, but this predates the Red Hat acquisition by a looong time. IBM have been a major reseller of RHEL for those migrations for years, this just means they take the software as well as the services revenue, and (they hope) can sell RH software into more of those conservative accounts by bundling it under the IBM family.
- DannyBee 7y agoEverything you say was true in 2004, when i was there, and they tried to do the same thing with SuSe without buying it.
- goatinaboat 7y agoIBM's customers have been slowly transitioning from proprietary IBM OSs (AIX, z/OS) to Linux for a lot of their workloads Yes, but that’s only a coincidence. What they have really been doing is transitioning from proprietary to commodity hardware. Which IBM no longer makes. Where does IBM make money? Mainframe sales. There can be only one winner here... IBM will need to kill off their mainframe business to justify this purchase, something they have proved very reluctant to do.
- rafiki6 7y agoIBM makes most of their revenue from their global technology services division, followed by their software division and then global business services division. A small fraction of their revenue comes from their mainframe/hardware business now. In essence that business only lives for legacy purposes.
- goatinaboat 7y agoMainframes were driving growth as recently as last year https://www.datacenterknowledge.com/ibm/mainframes-continue-driving-bulk-ibms-growth https://www.datacenterknowledge.com/ibm/mainframes-continue-...
- josho 7y agoThere is no reason to discontinue their mainframe business. Banks and other institutions have applications running successfully on those platforms. The industry has learned that it is better to integrate applications than to replace—especially when the replacement is a 40 year old app that runs the business. IBM’s mainframe margins are safe for decades to come.
- goatinaboat 7y agoBut, don’t you see the paradox there? If customers are happy with their mainframe why would they switch to Red Hat? And if they don’t want to switch why did IBM buy it?
- SteveNuts 7y agoMy thoughts are because IBM can see the metrics about where the Unix/Linux market is heading, especially in the age of the cloud. The hyperscale clouds are all running various Linux distributions, not AIX. FWIW my experience is showing large enterprises putting their Unix environments on life support/maintenance only mode, and not expanding their Unix usage. Seems like IBM is hedging their future on Linux.
- gridlockd 7y ago> Can someone explain why Red Hat is so valuable? The better question is, why did it cost so much? First of all, Red Hat makes a lot of money and it has a solid market position. Secondly, you tend to overpay in an acquisition, because it is a huge amount of sudden demand. Lastly, pretty much all stock is "overvalued" right now, because money is cheap (see my other comment). > Why would IBM put such a big bet? Because it is a giant corporate monstrosity that cannot really innovate by itself anymore. It still can buy things though.
- streetcat1 7y agoBecuase of kubernetes. The platform of platforms. Kubernetes is the andriod to amazon iphone (in analogy). It is the only way to get out of cloud vendor lock in. IBM is mainly a consultancy business, so they basically back integrated with the cloud os - kubernetes, or more specifically in this case - open shift. The only issue here is that are around 23 or more certified kubernetes distors, so this might have been an expansive price to pay.
- mike_hearn 7y agoKubernetes has nothing to do with cloud vendor lockin. I don't know where you're getting this from. Any hosting provider can spin you up some managed Linux nodes on a bunch of distros and they can be admined by the same tools and same people. That's why all the big clouds spend so much effort creating new services with custom APIs that aren't just "run a process in a chroot jail with fiddly bits". Big Data, AI and so on. That container will still need to store data somewhere, get traffic from somewhere else, etc, and they want to sell you services to do that. If anything I am skeptical about Kubernetes' future. Not in the short term, k8s/docker are the MongoDB of the late 2010s and the same sorts of people are jumping on the bandwagon. But look at the discussion about the AMD EPYCs in Google Cloud. Big machines are now getting so big that a bog standard OS running a bunch of processes is going to provide more than enough power for even very large websites. One machine now provides more power than a whole rack used to, and horizontal scaling technologies are expensive. A research paper from 2013 showed that just scaling up beat the performance of scaling up for virtually all jobs analysed, which came from Microsoft, Yahoo, and Facebook. So the sorts of companies that are poster-children for this kind of cloud technology. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261862149_Scale-up_vs_scale-out_for_Hadoop_time_to_rethink https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261862149_Scale-up_... There's not much career or intellectual capital to be gained by just running things on big boxes, but, eventually the cost effectiveness of this will become hard to ignore.
- streetcat1 7y agoI getting it from Jo Beda, the CTO of heptio (now VMWARE). More specifically , from his definition of cloud native. A cloud native system is a system that manage its resources via an API. The vendor locking in this case is the cloud API. I.e. if I want a resource (e.g. a VM) , I need to use the EC2 api. With kubernetes, I write to the kuberentes API which is open source, cloud vendor natural. However, and this the key to my comments - kubernetes is the platform of platforms. It is an API platform and not just an API. In the future (some would say near future), all of the cloud services will be offered as kubernetes APIs (via a set of domain specific CRD). I am currently working on the AI platform. As for the big machines comments. I absolutely agree. However, I would like to ignore the actual hardware (banning some sort of HA that would require at least 2 machines).
- mathattack 7y agoGives them another property for their sales and audit teams to use to generate revenue. (That’s the logic. I don’t think it will work though)
- ethbro 7y agoBecause you can only choose from houses that are for sale, when you're buying.
- AdrianB1 7y agoWall Street expects infinite growth from all companies, otherwise the CEO's will be fired. You can grow if you can grow your user base, your usage per user, prices or any combination of this OR you can grow if you expand your portfolio of things you sell. To expand the portfolio the easiest way for a mammoth turtle like IBM (and many others) is to purchase companies that have products. It has nothing to do with IBM or Red Hat, it is all driven by Wall Street expectations.