4 ms·
There's a lot not mentioned. How do they move the rotor magnets in field weakening? How do they reconfigure the coils? How do they get 20 percent more efficienc
by phkahler 7y ago
There's a lot not mentioned. How do they move the rotor magnets in field weakening? How do they reconfigure the coils? How do they get 20 percent more efficiency when most are already over 90-95 percent?
- Mvandenbergh 7y agoI think they must be claiming a 20% improvement on the 90% baseline, otherwise it doesn't make any sense.
- marvin 7y agoOnce again emphasizing the importance of separating between percent and percentage point :P
- randallsquared 7y agoSo, 90% improved to 92%? That's not nothin'...
- beojan 7y agoThat's still impossible. 20% of 90% is 18%.
- callesgg 7y agoA 20% improvent would be a 20% closer to 100% specifically 20% out of the remaining 10% so 2% overall improvement. From 90% to 92%
- microcolonel 7y ago20% less energy dissipated as heat.
- dickbutt69 7y agoI assumed they mean overall efficiency of a vehicle since supposedly it won't be needing a gearbox and the writer of the article is an arsetard.
- chrismorgan 7y agoNot that it’s what’s going on here, but as an aside: it’s possible to get over 100% efficiency, so long as you can take from the environment to achieve it. Reverse-cycle air conditioners routinely get 300–400% efficiency when heating, because they’re moving heat that already exists, rather than generating new heat. As a layman, how it sounds to me is that your 90–95% figure is the optimal efficiency, but electric cars don’t spend most of their time driving their motors at the speeds that yield this optimal efficiency; this motor, then, has a wider range of speeds at which it can be optimal. They’re also taking reduced weight into account. Hence talking about all this in terms of range rather than electrical efficiency.
- jbay808 7y agoThey probably mean something along the lines of a 20% reduction in losses. Or, they're comparing at an operating point that is far from peak efficiency. Motors can have 70% or lower efficiency when running at low speeds. If efficiency is 90%, then 10% is waste; cut that by 20%, and your motor efficiency is now 92%. Something like that. There's a lot of ways they can arrange the math, not to mention it's not clear which motor they're comparing to, which makes this kind of claim very vague. They should just state the efficiency they get.