3 ms·
I have a problem with the above post, but I don't think your comment is much better because of it's first half. The problem with the above post is that it lack
by BoorishBears 7y ago
I have a problem with the above post, but I don't think your comment is much better because of it's first half.
The problem with the above post is that it lacks substance, attacking things like using "um" in text is not productive.
Hacker News is an international website, we should remember that different cultures interact with the internet very differently.
I saw the shorthand and interpreted it as the poster probably not being from a western country rather than taking it as some personal slight or indication that the poster doesn't respect their audience on HN.
If the poster had made a more substantive point, I'd hate to see people attack them for using "um" or some shorthand here and there.
- lazylizard 7y agoI'm only saying I'm surprised that the author was surprised. If you go poking tigers with sticks. Then at least be prepared to get bitten.
- lazylizard 7y agoI mean. Is the author naive? Gullible? Or just having a professional need to submit an article? C'mon. She's saying bad things about them. She's saying they're bad folks. And she's expecting them to not at least reply in kind?
- michaelmrose 7y agoThe thing is that they ARE bad folks in much the same way that the Cigarette companies were and are bad folks. We needed people that are better folks than you or I that are capable and willing to suffer personal hardship to make the world a slightly less shitty place.
- lazylizard 7y agoI dunno what the world needs. But i think its interesting that she thinks criticism is a 1 way street. She can criticise monsanto. Thats it?
- michaelmrose 7y agoWhy are you so emotionally invested in defending an evil megacorp?
- lazylizard 7y agoAm i? Have i? I only think that was a pointless article....she's surprised the tiger bit her after she poked it with a stick? Why are you so worked up about the english grammar?
- lazylizard 7y agoIn fact. Bullying small firms is easier. They probably don't have the resources to fight back. But monsanto are like professional evil doers. Surely they have whole departments dedicated to doing whatever she's accusing them of doing.
- lazylizard 7y agoAnd indeed i don't come from an occidental country. English is not my native language.
- michaelmrose 7y agoWriting out umm instead of thinking it and saying u when you mean "you" aren't the artifacts of different nationalities and the way they communicate. They are the artifacts of lower quality English language communities like facebook. The post is jarring because it says nothing of substance and it says it badly. Prompting people to communicate better is worth doing.
- lazylizard 7y agoI take issue with "lower quality". Who is wise enough to judge? I say English is exactly how i write it. Or speak it. English is not stagnant. The epitome of high quality in your head now. Will be as quaint as chaucer in time to come.
- lazylizard 7y agoBut yes. Doing things like not starting sentences with "because". Not writing down the ums n ers. Seem to go well with old folks.
- lazylizard 7y agoBut ya. Usually i dun run things with the -vvv flag.
- HenryBemis 7y agoI always have a problem (me-my problem, not the other party's) when ome missuses the language, written or spoken, to spin something around and says A --> means B, "because language is a living thing and meanings change" to suit their message, but not the truth. The parent message was flagged, thus I didn't have a chance to read it, but from the above comments and your comments I get it that. > English is not stagnant No it's not, but potato means potato, and cancer means cancer. How you read it or speak it is your thing. And one of Quality's definitions is: "compliance to specifications". I would like to believe that the audience here is mostly high quality audience, I have to admit that language barriers exist that would make some people seem less eloquent, but by your definition we'll end up having "Idiocracy" (what humour, food, health, etc. may become).