6 ms·
Monsanto built a step-by-step strategy to destroy my reputation
- m463 7y agoMakes me think about the (fiction) book "The Doubt Factory" by Paolo Bacigalupi
- mgamache 7y agoA company complaining to editors? Routine crap. Hiring FTI to pose as a journalist? Hiring people to post fake reviews on a book you don't like? Seems illegal, but I don't know. Are there US laws that prevent such actions?
- sverige 7y agoEven if there were such laws, they would be very difficult to enforce. Monsanto certainly isn't the only company that does this. I'm sure that fake book reviews are very common. Worse, there are entire subjects that have been pushed aside by interested parties systematically building a consensus through media that some topics are "discredited" or "unfounded" or "unproven" theories, or even "conspiracy theories," to the point where most people will automatically dismiss them if they are brought up in conversation. The difficulty is that if you don't have a direct interest in the subject, you are very unlikely to spend the energy to investigate the subject yourself and make an informed decision, and those who want to suppress backlash know that. "Roundup? I never use that stuff. Who cares?"
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoAt this point it sorts of starts to be the collective responsibility of us all to not let these people win. If people knowledgeable about the subject remain silent, the message of the malicious actors becomes the signal in the noise.
- stubish 7y agoPossibly attempting to suppress evidence or similar laws against biasing court cases. It might even take down executives eventually; they knew, and they attempted to cover it up. It might not be illegal, but it can certainly be used as evidence to help prosecute things that are illegal.
- mirimir 7y agoIANAL, but I don't believe that a smear campaign against her would be illegal in the US. I mean, she's arguably a public figure, so a libel case wouldn't stand. Indeed, it would have been a better article if she had focused on how common this stuff is. And just used her own experience as the lead.
- pergadad 7y agoA company preparing a 20 point action plan on how to discredit someone doesn't seem normal or legal (if implemented) to me.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> I mean, she's arguably a public figure, so a libel case wouldn't stand. No, it would just require evidence of actual malice: that is, knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth.
- mirimir 7y agoIs that true in the US? I thought that the bar was pretty high for public figures. I mean, consider what people say in political campaigns. Lies and malice (i.e., prevent their election) are common.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Is that true in the US? I thought that the bar was pretty high for public figures. “Actual malice” is a much higher bar than is generally in place for libel, but it is not an insurmountable bar. > I mean, consider what people say in political campaigns. Litigation over political campaign statements for defamation is fruitless for reasons aside from the legal standard to win a judgement; it takes to long to get a final verdict, but more importantly the litigation itself keeps whatever damaging claim you are trying to suppress at the center of the news, doing your opponents work for them.
- mirimir 7y ago
- lazylizard 7y agoUm. You take stick n poke the tiger. U expecting the tiger to respond how?
- michaelmrose 7y agoYou would write better posts if you imagine yourself writing a physical letter in a professional capacity rather than tweeting. For example, Um is a sound we make while composing a thought it has no place in the written form. People commonly abbreviate things like "you" as u because typing letters by hitting a numeric keypad the correct number of times is incredibly cumbersome whereas everyone now has a passable keyboard even on their phone. Please write out the entire word. Once you get past all that the point made is very shallow and ill formed. It suggests that because the world is rife with bad behavior by powerful people that this is uninteresting. I disagree. If you have something substantive to say about the matter feel free to express it. Instead of posting low effort
- BoorishBears 7y agoI have a problem with the above post, but I don't think your comment is much better because of it's first half. The problem with the above post is that it lacks substance, attacking things like using "um" in text is not productive. Hacker News is an international website, we should remember that different cultures interact with the internet very differently. I saw the shorthand and interpreted it as the poster probably not being from a western country rather than taking it as some personal slight or indication that the poster doesn't respect their audience on HN. If the poster had made a more substantive point, I'd hate to see people attack them for using "um" or some shorthand here and there.
- lazylizard 7y agoI'm only saying I'm surprised that the author was surprised. If you go poking tigers with sticks. Then at least be prepared to get bitten.
- 7y ago
- acd10j 7y agoOh wow, how would we know that some corporate lobbyists or worse some government agency is not monitoring HN right now and propagating their agenda here in comment section. How can we detect that and how can we trust anyone else ?
- jchw 7y agoIf done well, how would something like that ever be possible to detect? Unfortunately, well-resourced malicious actors can stack the decks :( I now question every time I saw fairly vehement defense of Monsanto in comments sections and wonder if that defense was at least inspired by paid internet commenters and posters, even if it wasn’t directly them. Who really controls the narrative?
- Consultant32452 7y agoWhat really boils the noggin is realizing that it's not just "other" people who fall for this. We all do. Some portion of all of our political, economic, and moral views were put into our heads by corporate or government propaganda.
- mcintyre1994 7y agoThere’s a subreddit about this /r/hailcorporate. Some stuff there seems pretty benign but sometimes you get really blatant advertising by brand new accounts. It’d be silly if they weren’t also commenting.
- pjc50 7y agoThis definitely does happen, and occasionally it's really blatent.
- armitron 7y agoIt has been happening for years, on HN too. Astroturfing used to be extremely obvious and you could quickly verify by looking at someone's comment history. No longer the case I'm afraid, since accounts are either bought outright or pre-processed by intermediaries to have varied histories.
- 7y ago
- shadowbanme 7y agoI mean, it sounds like she built a step by step strategy to destroy Monsanto’s reputation, so it seems disingenuous to be shocked when they respond in kind.