3 ms·
"The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgobli
by chrisco255 7y ago
"The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary." -HL Mencken
I agree with your sentiment. I often ask people what percentage of the warming is due to CO2 emissions and what percent is due to natural fluctuations. And I struggle to receive an answer. There is nothing about the 20th (or 19th) century that makes it some sort of end all be all yard stick for permanent climate expectations on the planet.
People will usually retort with an admission that the climate is always changing, has always been changing, and will always be changing, but they resort to the argument that the climate "has never changed this quickly". Which is bogus and ignores even relatively recent periods of rapid and consequential climate change as the Medieval Warming Period and the Little Ice Age, both occuring this millennium, which is a blink of an eye on a geological scale.
The alarmism is completely unwarranted and counter productive. If we were to disappear off the planet tomorrow, what would happen? Would the earth continue to warm or would it enter a cooling phase?
- krastanov 7y agouhm... you mean you are asking for this plot I found with a minute of googling (reputable sources referenced): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attribution_of_recent_climate_change#/media/File:Climate_Change_Attribution.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attribution_of_recent_climate_... Edit: here is a pretty cool interactive version of the plot https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2015-whats-warming-the-world/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2015-whats-warming-the-wo... Edit 2: To the dead comment below, this is the whole point of "sources", something that actually refers to measurements/models/peer review, which all are fallible on their own, but together are fault-tolerant. Unlike the (rather small) petition you refer to that makes claim without any supporting data.
- showdeadplease 7y ago83 Italian scientists recently signed a letter to their government saying that the AGW hypothesis is unproven and largely false. But you won't see that on Wikipedia or Bloomberg, just pretty pictures with "reputable" sources. Of course, science is all about consensus, right? That's what John Cook says, anyway, and he's so "skeptical."
- dontreact 7y agoThere is extensive science answering your question. Most of it is caused by humans and not other factors. If humans disappeared the co2 already in the atmosphere would still cause some warming but not nearly as much as if we continue to emit even more of it.
- dontreact 7y agohttps://www.ucsusa.org/global-warming/science-and-impacts/science/human-contribution-to-gw-faq.html https://www.ucsusa.org/global-warming/science-and-impacts/sc... Why haven’t you looked to scientists for the answer to your question? I found this in about 10 seconds using google.
- elihu 7y agoMost of the CO2 emissions are natural, but they aren't the main concern. In the Northern hemisphere growing season, atmospheric CO2 declines sharply. In the fall and winter, the leaves fall off of trees and decompose, and that CO2 goes right back into the atmosphere. We don't worry about that CO2 because it's part of a natural cycle that absorbs and emits roughly equal amounts of carbon dioxide. If you look at an atmospheric CO2 plot over time, you'll notice that it's a sawtooth, for the reasons I just described. However, this sawtooth has an upward slant. That's the part we're worried about, and that's the part that humans are responsible for. We're pulling carbon out of the ground and burning it, and there isn't any natural process to cancel that out on the scale of what we're doing. So far, atmospheric CO2 has gone from about 280 parts per million before the industrial revolution to about 420 or so now. That's a pretty big change, and it's happening faster than ecosystems can adapt to it. It is also having an increasing impact on human life. Here's something to put the current rate of change into historical context: https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/
- chrisco255 7y agoI love xkcd but it's not a very good source for scientific argument. It's a pop science cartoon. The cartoon isn't accurate and misses a lot of major temperature swings. See this chart on second page "Long Term Trends in Climate Variability of Caucasus Region 1Bakhram S. Nurtaev, 2Lali Nurtaev" http://openjournals.gela.org.ge/index.php/GGS/article/viewFile/1886/pdf http://openjournals.gela.org.ge/index.php/GGS/article/viewFi...
- eesmith 7y agoHow neat to have a reference to the Journal of the Georgian Geophysical Society. I so rarely get to see Georgian script, like in the subsequent paper by ბ. ნურტაევი and ლ. ნურტაევი (last page on the document). What makes it odd, however, is that the chart you mentioned is an uncited reprint of a chart made by noted global warming denialist David Archibald. See https://wattsupwiththat.com/2011/02/12/david-archibald-on-climate-and-energy-security/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2011/02/12/david-archibald-on-cl... . You'll note that this paper by Nurtaev and Nurtaev uses a low quality image paste, so almost certainly did not generate it themselves. Also odd is the source citations, from Dansgaard (1969) and Schönwiese (1995). You'll note that those are 1) not stated in the references, and 2) they are very old, at 50 and nearly 25 years, respectively. Compare that to the citations in the xkcd comic, which are to 2012 and 2013. This is important because we've improved our understanding of the temperature records. The xkcd comic notes "Medieval warm period in Europe and some northern regions (too regional to affect the global average much)" and Wikipedia's entry for the Medieval Warm Period comments "Other regions were colder, such as the tropical Pacific. Averaged global mean temperatures have been calculated to be similar to early-mid 20th century warming" While the chart in Nurtaev and Nurtaev says there is a distinct global warming during that period. How odd that they use information which is so out of date. How odd that the paper promotes a solar model which has long been demonstrated to be wrong - and mostly only lives among the fringe group of global warming denialists. How odd that you decided to post a link to this paper, instead of the source material, and argued that it was more accurate when it appears to be less. Could you describe how you came across this paper, and what about it lead you to conclude it was a more accurate source of information?
- orthecreedence 7y ago> I often ask people what percentage of the warming is due to CO2 emissions and what percent is due to natural fluctuations. Maybe you should try reading something other than your CLIMATE CHANGE IS A LIBERAL HOAX facebook group news articles. You'll find that the fluctuations we're seeing now are not in any way natural...they are "unpresidented" as you might put it.