4 ms·
I am especially infuriated by how it repeats a common misconception of infrared light as the epitome of "heat", as if it was some kind of separate particle.
by Terr_ 7y ago
I am especially infuriated by how it repeats a common misconception of infrared light as the epitome of "heat", as if it was some kind of separate particle.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoI'm not infuriated, but having teachers and other adults conflate IR with heat certainly added to my confusion about the physical world when I was a child.
- p1esk 7y agoSorry for a potentially stupid question: why do they need to convert heat into visible light? Why can't we convert heat directly into electricity at the same time as we convert visible light into electricity?
- jfengel 7y ago"Light" here is a misnomer. What they're doing is taking the wide array of infrared wavelengths and channeling them into a single wavelength. It's easier to build a solar cell that's tuned to that wavelength. I don't know why they're calling that "light". It's not clear to me if it means visible light. The paper seems to imply that it peaks in the near-infrared. They appear to be using "light" in the general sense of "photons"... but it's all photons. They're talking about very high temperatures, the kind that emit significant visible light as well.
- skosch 7y agoYou're confused – heat isn't being converted into anything. The article conflates the words "heat" and "infrared radiation", which are not at all the same thing. As a rule, everything around you glows – in other words, it emits photons. Some infrared ones, some visible ones, some ultraviolet (or even higher-frequency) ones. How much of each depends on the temperature of the material. Most things (e.g. you) are too cold to be visibly glowing, but they still emit plenty of infrared radiation. Now, standard solar cells convert visible photons into electricity. Any incoming infrared photons, however, aren't strong enough to kick any electrons loose, so they go to waste. Here, the researchers used carbon nanotubes to absorb the wasted infrared photons. This heats up the nanotubes, which then emit visible photons, which then increase electricity generation. There is no way to convert heat to electricity directly, unfortunately. However, you can get small amounts of electricity out of temperature differences: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_effect
- reaperducer 7y agoThis heats up the nanotubes, which then emit visible photons, which then increase electricity generation Once a solar cell is built with this technology, do you think there will be enough light emitted by the nanotubes to make the solar panels appear to glow, themselves? Because that would be pretty interesting.
- dlivingston 7y agoIf the solar panels appear glowing, it's because visible light is being dispersed away from the solar panel itself. The consequence of that would be wasted photons that could otherwise be converted into electricity. So, from a pragmatic perspective, I would say that no, they wouldn't glow - proper engineering would ensure these particles are collected.
- skosch 7y agoThe idea is to direct all of the nanotube-emitted light onto the PV cells, so hopefully you won't see anything. Citing the Rice article: > Because electrons in nanotubes can only travel in one direction, the aligned films are metallic in that direction while insulating in the perpendicular direction, an effect Naik called hyperbolic dispersion. Thermal photons can strike the film from any direction, but can only leave via one.
- p1esk 7y agoI see, thanks! Why are visible light photons "stronger" than infrared photons?
- elwell 7y agoWhat is the accurate model of infrared light vs. heat?
- skosch 7y agoHot things glow. Medium hot things (like you) emit lots of infrared light. Really hot things (like lightbulbs) emit infrared and visible light. Ridiculously hot things (like the sun) emit infrared, visible light, and higher-energy radiation (UV etc.). The exact details depend on the chemical composition of the material, but for a simple model, check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation
- dredmorbius 7y agoIt's a bit complicated, but taking a stab at it: All physical objects emit electromagnetic radiation corresponding to their temperature (as opposed to reflected, reaction-induced, or stimulated radiation, more below), with a corresponding blackbody radiation curve. Note that blackbody emissions don't have a specific frequency (say, unlike laser light), though the curve has a peak emission. Traditional incandescent light bulbs are blackbody emitters, as is a hot coal, the Sun and other stars, or the glowing elements of an electric radiant heater. Human eyes see blackbody radiation, in the visible range, as having a characteristic colour, which paradoxically gets bluer as the temperature gets higher, so the ruddy tones of low-voltage incandescent lamps are low colour temperature, and the intense white of halogen lamps are high colour temperatures. Blackbody radiation and colour temperatures are given in Kelvin, with typical visible light corresponding roughly to ~3,000 - 8,000K. You might also recognise these values from gamma or colour correction values on monitors and video equipment. (Colour temperatures were used to judge processing for ceramics and metal processing / firing / smelting processes as well. They're also used to classify stellar temperatures, and in conjunction with brightness and/or distance estimates can be used to find stellar sizes.) Infrared light is characteristic of peak blackbody emissions of bodies at or near "room temperature". So IR is not heat, but is associated with hot objects. Heat itself is ... thermal energy, which is its own complex thing. Since all EMR carries energy, all EMR heats objects in which it is absorbed. A sufficiently intense emission above the IR range will also heat an object. However hot objects in near proximity transfer a great deal of thermal energy directly as IR emissions. The illuminating capability of "white" light (typical solar emissions) allows a small amout of EMR energy to provide a high degree of visual information without imparting much heat on the illuminated objects (though it does impart some). Consider that even an (inefficient) 100W incandescent bulb, whilst hot to the touch, does not significantly heat the objects it is illuminating, and a far more efficient equivalent LED lamp, drawing about 15W of electrical power, accomplishes the same illuminating power with vastly less heat. We don't have to toast things to be able to see them, just bounce a small amount of (high-energy) visible light off of them. Not all light (or more accurately, EMR) is blackbody radiation. There can be chemically-emitted light, directly from chemical reactions. The blue glow of methane (natural gas) combustion is a chemical emission, contrasted with the yellow-white glow of a candle, actually blackbody emissions of suspended soot particles in the smoke plume. (There's a blue region of chemical emission at the base of the flame.) Chemical emissions are based on specific frequencies of EMR emitted as electrons transition between energy states, if I understand correctly are a quantum phenomenon. Fluourescent and LED lamps also work based on chemical / valance emissions, and operate in far narrower bands than blackbody emissions -- one of the reasons these lamps can appear harsher than incandescents. Similarly various chemical lamps, especially high- or low-pressure sodium vapour, formerly popular as street lighting, which emit in narrow bands (low-pressure especially). Some forms of ionizing radiation are also EMR emissions, at far higher energy levels, triggered by nuclear rather than electron emissions. Typically gamma-rays. And stimulated emissions such as lasers and masers are ... another phenomenon I understand only poorly, but are also tuned to very tight frequencies. Radio and microwave emitters are somewhat similar. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infrared https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infrared https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat