2 ms·
The hypothesis that there is no universal truth is self-defeating. It isn't necessarily wrong, but any deduction you would make from it meaningless, and if you
by tsimionescu 7y ago
The hypothesis that there is no universal truth is self-defeating. It isn't necessarily wrong, but any deduction you would make from it meaningless, and if you truly choose to believe you should fall into solipsism.
You yourself must believe in some universal truths, otherwise you would not attempt to communicate with other beings.
So, in order to have any kind of discussion, you must start from a point where you believe that at least a large part of everyday experience (including other beings, their minds, physical objects, their interactions, our observation thereof and many others) exist in a meaningful sense, outside your own cognition.
Now, any extrapolation from these base assumptions, is what we should think of as physics. For example, if I assume my eyes exist and my perception of the world is meaningful, then I must also conclude that the moon I see through a telescope exists to the same extent, and it's motion as I observe it exists, and I can search for explanations of that motion etc.
If I were to not assume that my eyes perceive something which truly exists, I would have no reason to stand in front of a computer screen, hitting keys on my keyboard and watching the letters appear on the screen - it's possible in a very absolutist way, but it's simply not a productive way of looking at the world.
- pupe 7y agoYou’re making some unwarranted assumptions about what it would take to make a reasonable statement about the world. For example: >> any deduction you would make from it meaningless Deduction is only one mode of argument, and it is actually used the least in practical decision making and action. Hypothesis testing follows inductive reasoning, which works by filling in knowledge based on observed effects and theorization about plausible causes. Abduction is applied when diagnosing illnesses, trying to triangulate upon a best fit from multiple vectors, including both known postulates and inferences drawn from speculation pertaining to observed effects. Deduction is useful on paper, and that’s why its most commonly employed in math land. But in the real world, induction and abduction are king. >> You yourself must believe in some universal truth otherwise you would not attempt to communicate with other beings That’s a false misconception about relativism, especially common among those who seem perpetually trapped in math land. If you want to learn more about this I highly recommend that you read Barry Barnes’ and David Bloor’s chapter titled Relativism, rationalism and the sociology of knowledge in Hollis and Lukes 1982 edited volume Rationality and Relativism.