This case was appealed in 2009. The Ninth Circuit did not directly address the issue but, reading this summary, it appears the district court's ruling wasn't qu

This case was appealed in 2009. The Ninth Circuit did not directly address the issue but, reading this summary, it appears the district court's ruling wasn't quite as shocking as the headlines portrayed. See http://lctjournal.washington.edu/vol5/a23Hall.html http://lctjournal.washington.edu/vol5/a23Hall.html