3 ms·
How would that help here? These are generic, so there is no monopoly beyond the Hatch-Waxman Amendments, which is only 180 days. Now, if we got rid of trademar
by eesmith 7y ago
How would that help here? These are generic, so there is no monopoly beyond the Hatch-Waxman Amendments, which is only 180 days.
Now, if we got rid of trademarks, which gives a company the monopoly on the trade name, then it would of course be much easier for generics to start selling EpiPen-labeled injectors.
- coredog64 7y agoThe generic makers have already got that figured out. The box includes the text “The same active ingredients as X” and “Not manufactured by (maker of X)” is enough to inform consumers while not falling afoul of trademark law.
- lonelappde 7y agoThe problem with EpiPen is that you can only get an alternative if your doctor prescribees it. epipen is patented on the user interface so patients can't get the alternatives on an EpiPen prescription (which you will recall from Oracle v Google and others is usually not allowed, but pharma gets to do it).
- eesmith 7y agoI mean to use EpiPen here in the same generic sense that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epinephrine_autoinjector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epinephrine_autoinjector uses in sentences like "Teva Pharmaceuticals filed an ANDA to market a generic EpiPen" and "Sandoz submitted an ANDA to sell a generic EpiPen". Since "The first modern epinephrine autoinjector, the EpiPen, was invented in the mid-1970s at Survival Technology in Bethesda, Maryland by Sheldon Kaplan[10][11] and was first approved for marketing by the FDA in 1987", at least those patents have expired. And this article is, after all, talking about generics - authorized generics, certainly, but still generics. However, you are right - the "Epipen" is a trademark for an epinephrine autoinjector. As such, it can be applied to many things, eg, "Sudafed" packages might not contain pseudoephedrine as they once all did.
- sokoloff 7y agoI don't see what getting rid of trademarks will do to help consumers. It's not like people who need an epinephrine auto-injector are confused and think that only Epipens exist in that market. Hell, I don't need one and I'm well aware. If you want an Advil, I think you should be able to buy Advil. If you want 200mg ibuprofen, you can also shop for that, but if you happen to know that you prefer the outer pill smoothness and taste of genuine Advil, you are harmed by having the generic ibuprofen (without that same outer coating) be able to be advertised as "Advil" (rather than merely as "the same active ingredient as Advil").