5 ms·
the US withholding soybeans... does what? There was a piece about this on the radio a few months ago. It's actually a big deal. My memory isn't exact, becaus
by reaperducer 7y ago
the US withholding soybeans... does what?
There was a piece about this on the radio a few months ago. It's actually a big deal. My memory isn't exact, because of the passage of time, but essentially, China needs America's soybeans because it can't grow enough of them on its own. And it needs the soybeans to feed its livestock in order to feed its people.
The natural thought is, "China can just buy soybeans elsewhere." Which is true. Except that there are not enough countries producing soybeans for export to fill the quantity that China requires.
A more important problem for China is seasonality. When America's soybeans are ready to harvest, Brazil's soybeans are just being planted, and vice versa.
So it leaves China eventually in a position where it can't/won't get soybeans from the U.S., Brazil doesn't have any soybeans to send, and none of the other countries can make up the defecit.
Therein lies the rub.
- petre 7y agoTotalitarian governments do not care too much about their people or what they're eating. For them people are mere means of production, just like tractors or medieval peons. They only care about exports and hard currency. If soybeans are used to feed what becomes exported goods (cattle, beef?), then it's a problem. If there's a shortage of soy sauce, no so much of a problem. Most of that would go to exports anyway, while the majority of Chinese people will use something else in their food.
- User23 7y agoSoybeans are literally a commodity. Some third country will just buy the US soybeans and sell them to China. Edit: Commodities are fungible. They are things like gold, pork bellies, soybeans, and so on where there is no meaningful difference based on where they were produced. Buyers from some third country will buy soybeans from the USA, relabel them as originating in their country, and flip them to China for a profit. Trade circumvention is nothing new[1]. The US seller doesn't even have to be complicit, once they deliver to the third party they have no control over the labeling and they're not liable to care much either. Edit: Regarding 5G hardware: "The basic idea is that there is little differentiation between a commodity coming from one producer and the same commodity from another producer. A barrel of oil is basically the same product, regardless of the producer. By contrast, for electronics merchandise, the quality and features of a given product may be completely different depending on the producer."[2] So, no, 5G hardware is not a commodity. [1] https://agmetalminer.com/2017/05/24/what-is-trade-circumvention-hint-its-certainly-nothing-new/ https://agmetalminer.com/2017/05/24/what-is-trade-circumvent... [2] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/commodity.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/commodity.asp
- AmVess 7y agoThat's not how things work.
- kolanos 7y agoAnd 5G equipment is not a commodity?
- pjc50 7y agoNo? It's something with basically one and a bit suppliers and a large patent pool.
- mevile 7y ago> Buyers from some third country will buy soybeans from the USA This isn't happening. US farmers are not selling as many soy beans as they used to. The year over year soy bean export decline was in the billions of dollars.
- chvid 7y agoI may be a bit naive when it comes to international politics but when I look at a world map; I think there is one obvious place for China to get its soybeans: Russia (and other former Soviet republics). This massive piece of land may not have the effective and modern agriculture industry of USA but with enough investment and stable demand, it could have.
- pavs 7y agoIts already happening: https://www.caixinglobal.com/2019-08-06/chinese-farmers-are-growing-soybeans-in-russia-as-china-substitutes-us-suppliers-101448063.html https://www.caixinglobal.com/2019-08-06/chinese-farmers-are-...
- Longlius 7y agoTerraforming a chunk of land like the Russian east to turn it into productive farmland is possible (Brazil did something similar), but it's expensive, time-consuming, and temporary. China and Russia actually have a somewhat-standoffish relationship, and it's unlikely that Russia would invite Chinese investment into a region that it sees as a target for Chinese expansionists.
- Theodores 7y agoThis is happening exactly as you suspect. Russia is going places in the world of agriculture. It is a sector that is like telecoms in that a country that is behind can leapfrog the West by putting in new infrastructure. This agricultural trade is working out with new markets sought for organic produce, 'kosher' food items and plenty else. It is also two way so Russia is best buddies with Turkey these days with agricultural trade being part of the deal. Recently Russia signed up to have Huawei put in their 5G network. There is an on-going ambition to boost bilateral trade between China and Russia. Although dollar denominated, this trade is really 'barter', China get their soybeans, Russia get their 5G network. It is a win-win for both sides. Also to remember is that Russia has had sanctions that have led to a certain level of self sufficiency. Hence the emphasis on the agricultural sector as well as manufacturing things like cars. Weapons sales are part of the picture too, good for foreign currency reserves. I think patience is running out in China and in Russia with the UK/USA and their vassal states. The recent efforts to start conflict in Venezuela and Iran have been met with resolve from both China and Russia. The world was unipolar after 9/11 with Western dominance in telecoms. Now it is a multi-polar world and all of that early dominance in mobile telecoms has evaporated. Had the UK/USA not been fighting pointless wars in places like Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya (to name a few) then I don't think this situation of backwardness would have arisen.
- pvaldes 7y ago> it leaves China eventually in a position where it can't/won't get soybeans from the U.S. (Gasp), Chinese people face hard times of eating lots of fish, shellfish and Laminaria kelp for some months...