4 ms·
> The White House is holding off on a decision about licenses for U.S. companies to restart business with Huawei Technologies Co. after Beijing said it was halt
by jrochkind1 7y ago
> The White House is holding off on a decision about licenses for U.S. companies to restart business with Huawei Technologies Co. after Beijing said it was halting purchases of U.S. farming goods, according to people familiar with the matter.
> ...American businesses require a special license to supply goods to Huawei after the U.S. added the Chinese telecommunications giant to a trade blacklist in May over national-security concerns.
Uh... this doesn't sound like a decision based on national security concerns, right? If the US requires a special license to buy from Huawei due to ties to Chinese state security... what does that have to do with how many soybeans China buys, and why would the latter affect the former? Does Huawei have less worrisome ties to Chinese state security when China buys more soybeans?
This is obvious to everyone, that it's got nothing to do with national security concerns, it's just a trade war entirely unmoored from the previous free-trade consensus? The administration feels no need to hide it? And yet won't actually just say it either, they still provide a cover story they know is unbelievable? What's going on exactly? This really is a new phase of global politics.
- dirtyid 7y agoI say this as someone who is generally pro China, in context of US hegemony and great powers security competition, Trump is fucking up hard by conflating security concerns with trade concerns. It's vexing a lot of people on the hill. The cost benefit analysis of cheap Huawei hardware is favorable for many countries, but US is not one of them. Smacking nuclear sanction arresting Meng is the kind of calculus that appeals to his base that would rather see blood than sensible policy.
- Iv 7y agoI have seen critics of the administration saying that it was stupid to get angry at China because of the trade balance. That there were legitimate causes to get angry though: IP legislation and spying. I may be an attempt at making a decent case, but yeah, the bullying rhetoric muddy this issue. And that's really a dangerous slope for US to go in. If they make spying on their neighbors a criterion to impose tarrifs, I am sure Europe would be happy to push some obligations on the GAFA
- LMYahooTFY 7y agoI'm somewhat surprised this is confusing? The Executive is in charge of matters of national security, and thus is to use whatever is at its disposal to secure the nation. Why wouldn't you expect economic restrictions in national conflicts where we've agreed not to invade over such things?
- riffraff 7y agoThat's not what grandparent is saying. The argument is that instead of saying "we're delaying Huawei licenses in response to tariffs" they keep up the charade that it's something to do with security. I think the reason for this might have to do with denying the thing in front of a wto panel.
- scarejunba 7y agoWell, I mean, if we suspect Huawei is spying on us, then changed tariffs on soybeans don't change that, right?
- ojbyrne 7y agoI think it was obvious when they used national security concerns to put tariffs on aluminum and steel from Canada.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI can kind of understand it if you consider having a stable, strong steel and aluminum industry a national security issue. Say Canada pulls an Uber and just drives all US forges out of business with Uber cheap metals. Though I doubt we have thay much production capacity to actually put the US at risk.
- nicoburns 7y agoWhat gets me is the hypocrisy of the US. If it's a US industry/company under threat then it's a national security issue. If a foreign country has any protectionist policies, then they're communists and subject to sanctions and/or invasion and/or having their government toppled. I guess it's pretty straightforwardly self-serving, but surely all the other countries' economy's who get carelessly trashed constitute a bigger national security issue!
- saiya-jin 7y agoWhat gets me even more is how little common folks in US seem to care/understand that days of US being beacon of light, democracy and freedom are long gone and world in many places has overtook them. Quality of life (often even for top 1%) is not there anymore in many important aspects (at least those for me). There are still many great things going on / coming from there, but increasing number of matters are not and often just a sad story. The blonde guy's whims don't help at all. He pisses off practically everybody (apart from authoritative power grabbing figures), since his actions propagate on all of us eventually, never in good ways. Maybe common folks don't travel (far) to understand, watch only Fox News or... just don't care. It feels good to be raised and constantly told how special and better you are, when reality is often... not.
- 7y ago
- User23 7y agoTwo things. First, military security is entirely dependent on economic security. The productive capacity of a country's economy places a hard upper limit on its ability to produce materiel and thus effectively wage war. For obvious reasons trade can't be relied on when at war with the former trading partner. Second, this administration has been promising a trade war with China since before the election. It's not as if this is some kind of surprise. "CHYNA!" was a major campaign issue. For background: in the Nixon era, the USA decided that it would start a Marshall plan style trade deficit funded "investment" in China, with the belief that increasing the economic prosperity of the PRC would lead it to greater openness and generally becoming a tame satrapy of the US empire, much as Germany and Japan did. Now that it's clear that plan was a complete failure and the Chinese played the Americans for fools, some Americans, most notable among them the President, are looking to reset to a less inequitable trade relationship. Pretty much all major economic and political news from the pacific region is a consequence of this process. The Hong Kong riots? Turns out the CIA is involved[1]. North Korean missile launches? Yeah, how much real autonomy does the DPRK have when China decides to call shots? Edit: [1] https://www.reuters.com/video/2019/08/08/us-calls-china-thuggish-regime-for-singl?videoId=585060952 https://www.reuters.com/video/2019/08/08/us-calls-china-thug... (Obviously this is a pro-US outlet and frames it as innocuously as possible, but anyone who knows anything about tradecraft knows that "diplomat" in this context is a polite word for operative).
- vmlinuz 7y ago"The Hong Kong riots? Turns out the CIA is involved." I would be very interested in seeing any credible evidence that 'the CIA is involved' in the current Hong Kong protests. And I don't mean HKHermit scratching his stomach, or the hilarious training manual for non-verbal battle communications...
- saiya-jin 7y agoWell, generally speaking, this is exactly the ballpark CIA feels very much at home at and has tons of experience doing exactly this, for last 70+ years. On the other hand, Chinese involvement would also make sense, but things are too obviously pointing to their direction for my subjective taste. Maybe its both - US escalating situation just because that's what 3-letter agencies do, China obviously deeply involved since its a crucial place for them and literally their territory, which is rebelling and questioning Chinese supremacy. At the end, these are all just constant games for these folks.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- IllogicalLogic 7y agoThe US has screwed China for 2 centuries using phony excuses. The latest lies are not novel. White supremacists don't perform well (partly due to delusion) when their enemies are reasonably funded.
- factsaresacred 7y agoNobody has 'screwed China' more in the last two hundred years than the Chinese themselves. The commendable lifting on millions of Chinese citizens from poverty need not have been such a momentous task had the State not spent decades pushing those very same citizens into poverty in the first place.
- turtlecloud 7y agoThat is false and completely glosses over: 1. Japanese invasion during WW2 2. British promotion of opium to balance out trade to get Tea and other Chinese products back in the 1800s.
- Longlius 7y agoThe free-trade consensus has been dead for a while. We're only just starting to see the effects now because of how slow global politics moves. I figured the end was nigh when bipartisan efforts killed both the TPP and the TTIP. The political system in the US is no longer in favor of free trade.
- makomk 7y agoI believe that loosening up the restrictions on Huawei was one of the things China demanded in order to stop blocking purchases of US farm goods, and that's what ties the two together.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoI've said before and I'll say it again. Trump has no interest in settling the trade war with China any time soon. He is forcing companies out of China, and once China realizes this and tries to correct it, it will be too expensive for those companies to want to return. This will be viewed in posterity as the fastest cold war ever won against a Communist country.
- csomar 7y ago> this doesn't sound like a decision based on national security concerns, right? Do you also think that most of the troubling places that the US had to invade had, by coincidence, lots of oil in them?