3 ms·
I'm not arguing that the theorem is true. My point is that Cochrane is not claiming that the theorem is true to the real world (which hcknwscommenter seems to
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
I'm not arguing that the theorem is true. My point is that Cochrane is not claiming that the theorem is true to the real world (which hcknwscommenter seems to be claiming that Cochrane thinks).
Cochrane's point to me seems to be this: claims that "the multiplier is X" are even more naive and disconnected from the real world than Barro's theorem is.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Cochrane's point to me seems to be this: claims that "the multiplier is X" are even more naive and disconnected from the real world than Barro's theorem is. Which is, frankly, wrong. Claims that “the multiplier is X”, unlike Barro’s theorem, tend to be a posteriori arguments from analysis of real-world observations. They may be incomplete or flawed analysis and the conclusions may be wrong (as might the idea that there is a multiplier effect or, if there is, that it can be usefully summarized as a simple single multiplier), but they tend to be far more grounded in the real world than Barro’s theorem, which (aside from being circular in a subtle way) is a priori argument from premises that are both known to be false and which are based not on observation of the real world but idealized fantasies about the way the world (and particularly people) ought to work.