2 ms·
From that article: > “Theorem” means that if a bunch of assumptions, then borrowing has exactly the same effect as taxing. That doesn’t mean it’s true of the w
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
From that article:
> “Theorem” means that if a bunch of assumptions, then borrowing has exactly the same effect as taxing. That doesn’t mean it’s true of the world, but it means that if you want to defend stimulus, you have to tell us which of the “ifs” you disagree with.
> So the biggest impact of Barro’s theorem is not whether it is “right” or “wrong” as a description of the world. The biggest impact is that, if you are at all intellectually honest, it forces you to deal with why it is wrong. Many proponents do not do this; they just cite one assumption they don’t like, on the basis of intuition rather than real evidence, and go back to simplistic always-and-everywhere mulitipliers.
> Can’t the facts settle this argument? Alas, not easily – and both policy and economics would be better if they acknowledged this fact.
Did you even read the link?
- dragonwriter 7y agoBarro’s theorem is ivory tower economics based, like much ivory tower economics, in the assumptions of the rational choice model (which is not only possibly false, but is grounded in known-false assumptions and has repeatedly been proven to not predict real-world behavior), and, on top of that, the assumption that rational choice model works for individuals (which it doesn't) it assumes that it also does for families as effectively infinite-lifespan invididuals, and that capital markets are perfect (which they at best approximate), and that the path of government expenditures is fixed (since the path of government expenditures is determined at least in part by external economic conditions, this also makes the theorem circular since this assumption essentially includes the assumption that the different funding choice will have no externally visible economic effects that might affect future spending decisions.) Which of those assumptions, then, are wrong when dealing with the real world? All the ones that aren't simply begging the question are known to be false (though the one about capital markets may sometimes be a useful approximation), and the last is a sneaky assumption of what the argument is seeking to prove. Ml And those are the overt assumptions; it also assumes distribution of funding has no effect (or is an argument that borrowing is equivalent to a tax on exactly those who would lend, which, even if it is true, isn't a compelling argument because it's very difficult to mimic the targeting of borrowing with a tax.)
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI'm not arguing that the theorem is true. My point is that Cochrane is not claiming that the theorem is true to the real world (which hcknwscommenter seems to be claiming that Cochrane thinks). Cochrane's point to me seems to be this: claims that "the multiplier is X" are even more naive and disconnected from the real world than Barro's theorem is.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Cochrane's point to me seems to be this: claims that "the multiplier is X" are even more naive and disconnected from the real world than Barro's theorem is. Which is, frankly, wrong. Claims that “the multiplier is X”, unlike Barro’s theorem, tend to be a posteriori arguments from analysis of real-world observations. They may be incomplete or flawed analysis and the conclusions may be wrong (as might the idea that there is a multiplier effect or, if there is, that it can be usefully summarized as a simple single multiplier), but they tend to be far more grounded in the real world than Barro’s theorem, which (aside from being circular in a subtle way) is a priori argument from premises that are both known to be false and which are based not on observation of the real world but idealized fantasies about the way the world (and particularly people) ought to work.