3 ms·
They're claiming the factory wasn't authorized to manufacture the batteries, but that's only because they had an Apple logo on them, so he had them get rid of t
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
They're claiming the factory wasn't authorized to manufacture the batteries, but that's only because they had an Apple logo on them, so he had them get rid of the logo, which is the only thing that requires them to be "authorized" for. How is that even controversial? It seems to be the opposite of counterfeiting -- making it so the non-Apple battery doesn't have the Apple logo.
- saagarjha 7y agoRossman tried to claim that Apple seized the batteries (they didn't: the DHS did, independently of Apple) and claimed they were counterfeit when they weren't. Except he was actually smuggling illicit batteries into the country (willfully obfuscating this fact by hiding the Apple logo) and then making videos claiming that they were completely genuine and Apple didn't want him to have these because Apple personally hated him.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThey're only illicit if they have the Apple logo on them when they shouldn't, which is the whole point of taking it off.
- saagarjha 7y ago…but then you can't claim that there were genuine, as Rossman did in his videos.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoDo you have a link to the video? There is a difference between saying things like "manufactured to Apple spec" and claiming they were actually manufactured by Apple.
- saagarjha 7y agohttps://youtu.be/AVL65qwBGnw?t=43 https://youtu.be/AVL65qwBGnw?t=43
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThat's kind of ambiguous. He could mean original spec, as opposed to some junk using completely different components which is merely electrically compatible. The fact that he's then comparing "original" with "counterfeit" goes against that a little, but it feels more like confusion than malice, or using the same word in two different contexts. Saying these are original-spec components without Apple logos and not counterfeit might be true even if the reason they're not counterfeit is that they don't have Apple logos rather than because they followed the spec.
- neotek 7y agoThere's nothing ambiguous about it at all, they are indisputably not original components even if they adhere perfectly to the original spec.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThat's what I mean by using the same word in different contexts. Think AuthenticAMD rather than GenuineIntel. You have someone manufacturing components they're not claiming are Apple components, then they're original -- not original Apple, original That Other Company.