5 ms·
> A monopoly is not inherently bad. They often benefit users with increased efficiency and productivity. They're only bad when progress stagnates and/or prices
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
> A monopoly is not inherently bad. They often benefit users with increased efficiency and productivity. They're only bad when progress stagnates and/or prices rise.
My argument is every single monopoly eventually becomes 'bad' and makes progress stagnate and prices rise.
Just look at Google and Amazon. Up until I'd say late-ish 00s, nearly everyone loved Google and Amazon. I remember when Google search, GMail, Maps, street view, etc. first came out. I loved them, and I felt they were so much better than the competition. Same thing with Amazon - their selection was huge, great delivery and customer service.
I still use Google and Amazon for so much, but it's usually with reluctance and distaste. Check out Google search results these days. The ENTIRE first page about half way past the fold is ads, or AMP carousels, or shit I just want to get out of my way. But I still use them because with their heft and scale no one does long tail searches as comprehensively.
- wolco 7y agoNow that you mention it maps hasn't really improved since streetview. Search is worse. Gmail hasn't really changed much. I guess after it's launched new features are too difficult to add for google.
- eridius 7y agoBuilding new stuff is always more attractive to engineers than maintaining and incrementally improving existing stuff. Google suffers from this problem somewhat worse than most companies, where its best engineers jump to new projects and the existing products languish because it's not attractive to work on.
- glennpratt 7y agoWhat? All of these products probably have a miles long changelog. I mean, I can assume you don't care for the change, but it's there. Streetview was launched in 2007.
- radicalriddler 7y agoDid they not see Google Maps change to a globe late last year? Revolutionary! Take that Flat Earthers!
- asutekku 7y agoI mean, in the end it is just a map. If it works, don’t break it. However just recently they added an AR navigation to the mobile apps.
- ComputerGuru 7y agoIt’s still Mercator on mobile (iOS at least). How hard is it to push this change?
- wlesieutre 7y agoHow about the AR navigation on phones? https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/08/google-maps-ar-navigation-comes-to-iphones-and-android-devices/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/08/google-maps-ar-navig...
- alanh 7y agoThe Apple Maps 'street view' equivalent (coming in iOS 13) has a transition animation (for moving down the street) that absolutely knocks the socks off Google's. It was surprising to see just how strikingly better it is. I don't think Google changed it in that time.
- tlunter 7y agoRecommend taking a look at this blog post: https://www.justinobeirne.com/google-maps-moat https://www.justinobeirne.com/google-maps-moat the author has updated a couple times. The changes are subtle and are amazing for your benefit. Not seeing the change is them getting better at easing you into the new functionality, not them stagnating.
- johnday 7y agoI hate to point this out on HN but it does seem relevant. If you dislike Google's use of ads, why not block them? I think you've acknowledged that Google and Amazon provide the best services of their respective classes. Can we find a way to maintain that high standard without the crud that comes with it?
- dmix 7y agoI'm still not convinced someone couldn't build a better gmail. The web app is bloated and slow. The ads. The awkward design. Privacy issues. There's a bunch of benefits someone could offer. Fastmail tried but I still think it could be better and not based in Australia where privacy has been eroded. The barrier to entry for doing categorization, spam detection, search, autosuggestions, and even complex JS frontends is significantly lower than it's ever been. You could even offload some of the above challenges to the client with prepackaged ML models. The spam filtering stuff could even be open sourced and community run like Adblockers. Abuse could still be handled server side.
- ReidZB 7y agoI agree that Fastmail's location is problematic, but other than that, I would argue it is a better Gmail already, features-wise.