4 ms·
I'm curious why you think so (about the Z80, I mean). I seem to remember it being in very cheap computers as well (ZX Spectrum, doesn't get much cheaper than th
by pvg 16y ago
I'm curious why you think so (about the Z80, I mean). I seem to remember it being in very cheap computers as well (ZX Spectrum, doesn't get much cheaper than that) and was a great deal faster. I grew up with a 6502 and love it like a childhood pet but can't see how it 'ran rings' around the Z80.
- jonsen 16y agoI believe the 6502 could do things faster than the Z80. I once implemented the exact same program on a 6800 and a Z80. The 6800 is very close to the 6502. Speed wasn't an issue, but the Z80 version was noticeably bigger. And also felt more quirky to program.
- pvg 16y agoI believe the 6502 could do things faster than the Z80. Right, I was hoping someone might remember specifics. I don't think this is really true, in general. The 6800 is very close to the 6502 Not really.
- forinti 16y agoThe 6502 was faster at accessing memory. I remeber Elite running a lot better on a 2MHz BBC Micro than on any 3.58MHz Z80 based micro, like the MSXs.
- rbanffy 16y agoThe MSX 1 also had a hideous design flaw (for a gaming machine) that hid the framebuffer from the processor. IIRC, you had to do a couple IOs to get a single byte to or from the VRAM.
- wladimir 16y agoI remember the MSX2 had exactly the same flaw, it had a bigger video memory and some 2D acceleration primitives, but the access method was the same, through vpoke/vpeek.
- leoc 16y agoIn his talk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HW9AWBFH1sA#t=3m01s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HW9AWBFH1sA#t=3m01s Michael Steil claimed that the 6502 had 60% fewer transistors than the Z80 but was twice as fast (in clock terms, I presume), while the Z80 had more registers and allowed slighly denser code.
- mgedmin 16y agoSpecifically, the talk mentions that the 6502 was pipelined and could do many instructions in 2 clock cycles, while the Z80 needed at least 4. This translates to 2x the speed at the same clock rate.
- Flow 16y agoThe 6510(6502 plus IO-ports) could do no such thing. Fastest instructions used 2 cycles and 1 byte op-code.
- rbanffy 16y agoYou use two cycles, but the 6502 could execute the instruction while fetching the next one.
- Flow 16y agoThat's not the pattern I see when looking at the op-code/cycle chart. I recently implemented part of a C64-emulator in JavaScript and it seems very much like every step takes a cycle. For example the instructions NOP(or CLI, STI, INX etc), 1 byte, 2 cycles. 1 cycle for fetching the instruction and one for executing the fetched instruction. LDA addr,x seems to be pipelined a bit though. It's "AD lo hi" in memory and takes 4 cycles unless lo+x > 255, then it takes 5 cycles. The lo+x calculation seems to occur while hi is being read.
- rbanffy 16y agoI will have to dig up my 6502 documentation, but, IIRC, by the time the processor executed the NOP (CLI, INX etc) it already fetched the next instruction, so, if it's another NOP, it will complete in one cycle instead of two. Unless you crossed a page boundary, which implies a one-cycle penalty.