6 ms·
Are we going to make it? No. Global heating is pretty much inevitable. There's no taste for fixing it among the people who can actually do something. Politici
by onion2k 7y ago
Are we going to make it?
No.
Global heating is pretty much inevitable. There's no taste for fixing it among the people who can actually do something. Politicians don't see farther than their next term in office, and the rich don't need to fix it. It's not really a case of "if" any more. It's going to happen.
- Brakenshire 7y agoGlobal heating has already happened, we’re 1C up on preindustrial. The question is how high are we willing to go. Doing nothing will lead to another 6C, concerted serious action will be another 2C, and we could end up anywhere in between, depending on what and whether tipping points exist, as well as people’s good sense, and their willingness to elect politicians who will do something.
- esotericn 7y ago> Doing nothing will lead to another 6C Surely doing nothing (not actually doing nothing, but rather continuing to burn fossil fuels) leads to, well, ~ infinite warming until we run out of fuel? Or is the assumption that at 6c we're dead so whatever?
- Brakenshire 7y agoWithout big feedback loops you actually have to go out of your way to get above a certain level of warming. RCP8.5, for 8.5C of warming, involves a frankly silly quantity of emissions, I assume this is because CO2 absorbs at certain wavelengths and there are diminishing returns as concentrations get really high. Of course, we don’t know what the feedback loops are, they could kick in and take over. The IPCC is quite conservative about including feedback loops, and mainly deals with direct effects. But the same logic applies either way, within any reasonable range any reduction in CO2 emissions is worth pursuing. I also personally think the economics for certain low carbon technologies will dominate over a middle/long time period, just that as it stands they won’t take over quick enough to dramatically bring down emissions.
- hire_charts 7y agoWhat kinds of feedback loops is the IPCC known to exclude, and is there any serious study into what the potential consequences are? Like, how possible is it that there is a feedback loop that will push us well beyond the RCP8.5 scenario?
- Brakenshire 7y agoTwo examples I recall are the albedo changes from melting of on-land glaciers and ice-sheets, the IPCC thinks think will take hundreds of years. And then the Methane Clathrate idea, which is very controversial but could contribute to some degree. I don’t think anyone in the world can answer the question about how likely these feedback effects are, unfortunately!
- chmod775 7y agoSpeak for your own country. Where I live major political parties are now scrambling to adopt greener policies after losing big to green parties in the recent EU wide elections. Because people have shown that if they don't do it, they will vote for someone who will. There's also the issue of thousands of students rallying for greener policies every friday instead of attending school. It's been going on for some time and politicians are further under pressure because of that.
- marmaduke 7y ago> Speak for your own country This phrase might be applicable if each country had its own atmosphere.
- chmod775 7y agoMost countries have their own politicians and he was speaking of political will as if the political sitation was the way he described everywere.
- alfromspace 7y agoThat's great, but Europe could dial all emissions to zero right now there would be virtually no impact. Even the US doing the same would hardly put a dent in climate change's trajectory, and the issue people have is that we can't simply assume that if we overhaul our entire economies at ruinous cost, China (over 2x America's emissions now and increasing every day), India, Russia, etc will be inspired to get on board. We need a binding global solution. Domestic solutions seem worthless to me.
- chmod775 7y ago> overhaul our entire economies at ruinous cost Reading this gives me a headache. Guess what will WAY be worse than that? https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B5-lDJWCUAAwfya.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B5-lDJWCUAAwfya.jpg Also most of the developing countries, those people like you like to point their finger at and use as an excuse to keep dooming yourself, your planet and most of all your children's futures, will be hit first and the hardest by climate change. And they know it. China is already coming around.
- snarf21 7y agoI agree. This is a runaway train. The poor and undeveloped countries are going to have massive drought and starvation. Eventually, the dangers will be real enough to matter. It will also accelerate less rapidly after 1B people die. This is particularly sad as it could be avoided.
- Brakenshire 7y ago“Runaway train” is just rhetoric to avoid doing anything. There is a huge amount to play for and there is never a time at which it’s reasonable to give up. Even if you’re choosing between 5C and 6C, make that choice and don’t abdicate responsibility. By your admission, millions of people’s lives may rest on the decision.
- empath75 7y agoIt’s just being realistic. No country is going to do what it takes and the worst offenders are still increasing their emissions.
- reroute1 7y ago"No country is going to do what it takes" That's not being realistic. That is decidedly pessimistic and something that no one could say at this time.
- WarDores 7y agoLots of first world countries (including the United States, although admittedly not as fast as we could) are cutting emissions by either market forces or government fiat. By "No country", we're really talking about China and India.
- Brakenshire 7y agoChina’s doing a lot, they’ve played a big role in scaling up solar and batteries. They’re accelerating into the transition, directing growth from a carbon economy into massive investment into replacement technologies, which is not a bad idea.
- throwaway5752 7y agoYou seem to misunderstand the situation. This is the - very realistic - "collapse of civilization as we understand it" outcome by 2050. Collapse of global ecosystems and modern life as we know it.
- Brakenshire 7y agoCollapse by 2050 strikes me as very unlikely, unless there’s some massive feedback loop which kicks in. The difference between warming for RCP2.5 and RCP6 isn’t that great at 2050, it’s 2060-2080 where the real difference opens up, I think that’s when you get the collapse of civilisation outcomes become possible.
- throwaway5752 7y agoHere is some of your feedback loop: https://www.wunderground.com/cat6/New-Models-Point-More-Global-Warming-We-Expected https://www.wunderground.com/cat6/New-Models-Point-More-Glob.... The marine stratocumulus results are not good. Collapse by 2050 seems entirely reasonable and I expect that to move up new results have all been worse than modeled. Seriously: we are all going to fucking die from this if nobody does something, and soon. Except maybe a few billionaires in space or bunkers.
- Brakenshire 7y agoLooks like early stage research. We need to keep an eye on these sorts of things, but you’re doing more damage than you are helping by promoting theories which are not well established.
- throwaway5752 7y agoI'm definitely happy to be corrected, but I am curious how you arrived at that conclusion based on the article. There is a long term upward trend in the ECS upper bound, there is model convergence towards that new upper bound figure, and it agrees with recent satellite observations from CERES. I think this constitutes a fair amount of support that warrants my concern.