4 ms·
I do remember how Skype used to be end-to-end encrypted.
by snvzz 7y ago
I do remember how Skype used to be end-to-end encrypted.
- jchw 7y agoI don’t know much about how it worked but I’ve heard it described more like obfuscation than encryption. It also used to be P2P but that ended under Microsoft’s ownership. Funny enough, at one point Microsoft basically merged Skype and MSN, and the text chat parts of Skype started using “MSNP24”, a couple version numbers up from the latest MSN protocol, MSNP22. I never dug in to see how much it was really like MSNP from MSN because I lost interest in Skype not long after.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoP2P was really the key to Skype's privacy protections, AFAIK. I remember a lot of insanity in the P2P days, even when they had a bunch of their own supernodes holding everything together. Like photo shares and file sends not working if the person who posted them was offline when you finally saw them, which was especially annoying in group chat contexts. Skype's model was built really well for the world where everyone had a persistently-internet-connected desktop. But it's P2P nature was incredibly terrible once mobile became the norm.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoOnce they ditched p2p the quality derailed. The worst thing was the Skype mobile app trying to sync on my phone. It never seemed to cache convos well enough, it also would not sync properly between devices in regards to notifications. Also Skype would try to pull in my entire history. I feel like some P2P concepts stuck deeply within Skype and thats what left it so awkward.
- jchw 7y agoThe mobile app is probably why they ditched P2P. As much as I love old Skype, it existed in a pre-mobile world, and never translated well to phones... and in fact, most P2P platforms won't translate well to phones, since you at least need centralization for the push notifications. Such is life. Though to be clear, yeah, it didn't really fix the mobile app. It felt just as broken up to the moment I uninstalled Skype.
- swiley 7y ago>most P2P platforms won't translate well to phones, since you at least need centralization for the push notifications. Such is life This isn't a fact of life, this is a flaw in the API of most popular mobile OSes. Open source comunnity maintaned operating systems have solved the problem of providing a network service for handling push notifications (local or not) multiple times now and these companies have refused to implement them because it makes it much easier to create an ecosystem around their crap. This gives them controll and controll can be traded for money, it has aboslutely nothing to do with technology. That's just life
- jchw 7y agoI work for Google and use an iPhone so I can’t claim to be unbiased. (My eyes have been on the Librem phone, with some skepticism and lately mostly excitement, but I’m just not quite sold on it as a daily driver.) However, even if you allow apps to run in the background basically indefinitely as Android once did (there were IRC clients that Worked, using only the phone,) it simply is bad for battery life. Having multiple push services that are blessed to run periodically is also just not good for battery life. The proof is in the pudding; I switched to IRCCloud for IRC on the go after noticing what a terrible battery drain it was. Now, third party push services can certainly do better than IRC, but they’re still centralized. Decentralized networks are just not power efficient. It requires always on machines to be effective. I’m not saying I love the status quo, but it’s unclear how to do better. (Obligatory legal line noise: these are my own opinions and not those of my employer.)
- Fnoord 7y agoIf you need push notification, yes, it is going to cost (if its an Electron app, it'll cost you also RAM). Google provides such already, via GCM/Firebase. I mean, you could just run IRC in a TUI (e.g. Irssi or WeeChat) and connect to that via Mosh plus Tmux. You'd have low latency, 24/7 uptime, resuming, low resource usage... but no push notifications.
- giancarlostoro 7y ago
- rb808 7y agoI always thought some three lettered agency must have encouraged MS to buy Skype from its foreign owners for precisely that reason. The first 10 years at least MS did absolutely nothing with the company, as if it never really wanted to buy it.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoThat’s pretty silly. For one thing, it was already owned domestically before MS bought it. Second, you think MS spends 8.5 billion plus untild engineering resources and overhead as a favor to the US government?
- Retric 7y agoIt's unlikely, while the US government had real leverage via contract negotiations, Anti trust issues, etc. Skype looked like a solid investment at the time. Microsoft makes a lot of money from corporate clients so it's probably just another strategic acquisition that they did not know what to do with.
- joering2 7y agoObsolutely! At this point its just a matter of how big is government contract regarding scooping into Skype content. I could bet the billions MS soend have been easily recouped in first 2 years.
- imglorp 7y agoYep. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/11/microsoft-nsa-collaboration-user-data https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/11/microsoft-nsa-...
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoThat relates to court orders, which have been served on every company. It was also horribly misreported, with every affected company saying pretty publicly that this wasn’t accurate. There is a difference between being compelled to spend billions on a company just to provide wiretapping for feds, and buying a company with a wildly successful product then being asked to handle wiretaps after the fact. One of those is ridiculous, the other is expected.
- johannes1234321 7y agoMind that this - as I understand it - about cases where the automatic translation is being used in Skype (while I wonder how "sexy" phone sex via automatic translation might be ... In my imagination (you want to hear about that, right?) these could be people trying "funny" things with the translation ... or I underestimate the quality. And yes, doesn't mean MSFT doesn't have access to other communication and doesn't mean other cases aren't serious leaks of information to arbitrary contractors.