5 ms·
On my Mercedes key I always double click the lock button which entirely disabled the keyless features until I use the key again. Now the question is - is this
by gambiting 7y ago
On my Mercedes key I always double click the lock button which entirely disabled the keyless features until I use the key again.
Now the question is - is this actually safer? If some thieves arrive at my house to steal my car and their relay gadget doesn't work, are they going to give up, or are they going to break in and threaten me for the key? Now that's a question I don't like to think about too much.
- wycy 7y agoYou can probably rest assured that that won't happen. The type of thieves interested in quickly/easily/silently breaking into your car are probably not the same as the type of thieves who are willing to turn it into a violent crime. Probably.
- hugh-avherald 7y agoThey're going to give up. It's opportunistic, they're not going to risk robbery, or they'll think it's not working.
- jcims 7y agoYou would give up, as would most rational people. Once you’re committing felonies the primacy of rational thought could be called into question.
- dpark 7y agoNo. The typical person who is willing to steal a car is not willing to commit violent assault in order to take keys from you. Someone whose logic is so flawed that they think “oh well, felony” is probably not just stealing cars. At that point they might as well break into your house, murder you for your stuff, and then do the same for every house on the block. “Because felony”, right?
- jcims 7y agoSo ‘No.’ but then you go on to restate my point?
- dpark 7y agoNo. Your point seems to state that committing a felony implies that a criminal is automatically willing to escalate to any other crime, as if anything resembling rationality is impossible. I’m saying that’s absurd. Car thieves don’t generally commit war crimes.
- jcims 7y agoThis is what i said: >Once you’re committing felonies the primacy of rational thought could be called into question. This is what you're saying i said: >Your point seems to state that committing a felony implies that a criminal is automatically willing to escalate to any other crime, as if anything resembling rationality is impossible. See the difference?
- dpark 7y agoNo, I don’t see the difference. You said that someone committing one felony will escalate to another felony because they can’t think rationally. The question was whether someone who’s willing to break into a parked car to steal it is willing to break into a house to assault the car owner in order to take their keys to steal the same car. You said yes, or at least you implied “yes” extremely strongly. If you don’t believe the answer is “yes” then I don’t know what the point of your comment was. PS: The fact that you thought my absurd extrapolation of your statement was making the same point tells me that you do indeed believe a car thief is likely to escalate to far worse crimes “because felony”.
- kokx 7y agoIt is one thing to steal a car. Another to break in and threaten someone. Escalating that much is a lot more dangerous. Firstly, now you might know what they look like, or at least partially. But you can also bet that the police will put more time into finding thieves that threaten people in their homes over simple car thieves. Which is definitely not what they want. If you find a burglar in your home, the burglar is generally more likely to flee as quickly as possible, than pull a gun on you. Escalating to (the threat of) violence will likely make it harder for them, not easier.
- mannykannot 7y agoThe Mercedes double click is specifically mentioned in the article, where someone claims a theft occurred after using it. Two questions that immediately come to mind are 1) Is there feedback that the double-click was executed correctly? 2) If so, do you still get that feedback if the mechanism for disabling the keyless feature is interfered with in some way, e.g. by jamming?
- gambiting 7y agoOnce you double press the lock button, there is a red light that comes on the key and flashes twice. But the thing to remember here is that this only disables the keyless features on that key. If they had the spare key somewhere in the house and didn't double click on the spare, then the spare would have responded the the relay attack even if the main key was switched off.
- dagw 7y agoThieves don't want your car, they just want a car. If your car is too hard to steal they'll just take your neighbors instead.