3 ms·
Everyone in this thread is talking about how it's fake, but this does have an actual implication for the dangers of AGI. If every world government is scrambling
by whatshisface 7y ago
Everyone in this thread is talking about how it's fake, but this does have an actual implication for the dangers of AGI. If every world government is scrambling to pretend to have it, nobody will be able to tell when someone actually invents it.
- dmix 7y agoThat’s entering conspiracy territory. A government is just as likely to hide a massive revolution in AI as it would space flight with “alien technology”, which means extremely unlikely. The simple fact is they’d need the best minds of the world working on it and as we saw with the Manhattan project the people working on it tended to have the best grasp of the implications and wouldn’t keep it secret for long. Plus it’d turn whatever country had it into an economic powerhouse which is way more valuable than some classified intelligence product.
- whatshisface 7y agoThat's true today, but what about 30 or however many years from now, where AGI is only a few billion dollars away? Some government will do a Manhattan project, and when word gets out nobody will be able to tell it apart from the thousands of buzzword-driven parasitic schemes that preceeded it.
- mrkeen 7y agoStuxnet.
- dmix 7y agoWhat about it?
- iainmerrick 7y agoI think the idea is that there won't necessarily be any whistleblowers even if the secret project has dubious or even scary implications. I'm not sure the Manhattan Project is a great example either; who leaked that into the public domain? Or did you mean in some other sense?
- godelski 7y agoWhy is this a conspiracy theory? In the pejorative sense of the term (because conspiracy theory doesn't mean false). The USAF has been pretty open about how alien conspiracies help them. Makes it harder for enemies to distinguish fact from fiction. Sure the Russians know the aircraft at Area 51 aren't aliens, but it makes it harder to get good reports on capabilities of these aircraft. Op Sec is a major part of any agency. They always have been trying to obscure information. Many agencies have often both over and under reported their technological capabilities. This tactic has thousands of years of history and has been essential for all that time too. Propoganda is part of this too. At least I read the parent talking about it in this manner. As Op Sec. Which of course it is. Anything that a government agency officially releases is in some form or another Op Sec. That's not conspiracy. That's like saying that when corporations make public announcements that they aren't trying to do something beneficial for the company, even if it is damage control. Sure, we know they don't have AGI. But that's not what matters with Op Sec like this.