3 ms·
There are two questions here: 1) Is Google more evil than a hypothetical benchmark company producing similar products? 2) Is the product space Google works in
by roenxi 7y ago
There are two questions here:
1) Is Google more evil than a hypothetical benchmark company producing similar products?
2) Is the product space Google works in fundamentally bad?
(1) is a pretty clear no, Google is about the best we could hope for given that a single corporation is in the product spaces that they are in and trying to sell ads. (2) is much less clear, there are many historical instances where the existence of a Google would have magnified the damage done. Realistically it isn't just them either, the radical dropping cost of surveillance was raised the other day and Google's work is only a small component of that.
- cartlidge 7y agoIt isn't at all clear that (1) is true. Until recently, no-one was particularly concerned about companies which link advertisers and purchasers. Unless you say the hypothetical benchmark company is a company which tries to track you and build a database on you and basically spy on you, Google seems to be overtly more evil than any hypothetical benchmark company. Effectively you've defined yourself into a corner were the hypothetical benchmark company is Google, since they must be substantially identical in all relevant ways. It isn't sufficient that they are advertising mediators: no, they must be advertising mediators who track every detail of their users life. But even if we decide to compare within their business methods - not just their product space - and say, "given that they're Big Brother, are they an evil Big Brother or relatively more benign", it's not clear that they're benign. I have heard stories that leave my concerned (trying to produce a censored version for China, for instance, and gagging former workers who don't feel comfortable with that). I cannot provide evidence that they operate an evil business in an evil way, but it isn't clear that they don't. The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Google worries me more and more, even though I'm tied to them more and more.
- einpoklum 7y ago> 1) Is Google more evil than a hypothetical benchmark company producing similar products? My military dictatorship is well above category average as far as totalitarian states go! We put -0.2% less of our population in jail, and assassinate less than one third of our closest competitor! Now bow down before my statue please.