3 ms·
I don't see any contradiction, even if sites like 'facebook-login-help.com' are exactly the kind of clutter Markham would prefer did not rank at all. One compl
by gojomo 16y ago
I don't see any contradiction, even if sites like 'facebook-login-help.com' are exactly the kind of clutter Markham would prefer did not rank at all.
One complaint is wishing that the search results were better. From the perspective of one person, that might or might not ever happen – one person outside Google has very little influence on overall search quality trends.
The other action is living in the world as it is. If cynically-optimized results are going to dominate the top spots, and being in the top spots is a way to make a living, even people who would prefer cynical-optimization not be rewarded have to engage in it. (I'm sure there are lots of good people creating awful content for Demand Media and other mills; they're just responding to bad incentives.)
It's the same for anyone who's had to twist their original web writing/design/structure in a way that was solely directed at search engines, rather than primary users. Yes, lots of SEO advice is making the web more usable for people, as well. But not all of it, axiomatically.