2 ms·
> But that's not the worst issue. The real problem is: under what license is the whole kernel, once you linked together the common Linux parts (which are under
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> But that's not the worst issue. The real problem is: under what license is the whole kernel, once you linked together the common Linux parts (which are under GPL2) and the ZFS parts (which are under the CDDL)? The "mere aggregation" provisions of GPL2 clearly don't apply, and the licenses are incompatible (on purpose, it's been documented that CDDL was intentionally made incompatible with the GPL). Since the CDDL can't apply (due to the GPL parts), and the GPL can't apply (due to the CDDL parts), distributing the combined whole would be a copyright violation.
I asked for the counter argument, so, thank you—but this strikes me as totally silly. If I distribute a zip file with a Linux ISO and an OpenSolaris ISO, is that also a copyright violation?
It seems to me, the Linux kernel and the ZFS module aren't actually being put together until they arrive on the user's machine, and at that point, redistribution is irrelevant.