4 ms·
My $0.02: I came across Boeing's documentation for their "Boeing Update" solution. (think Windows Update, but for 787s). It described in detail how the planes
by jiggawatts 7y ago
My $0.02: I came across Boeing's documentation for their "Boeing Update" solution. (think Windows Update, but for 787s).
It described in detail how the planes are updated with new firmware for the avionics, entertainment system, and the engines. I was shocked to learn that the 787 uses a lot of COTS kit internally, such as standard WiFi and Ethernet connections. There's an RJ-45 jack at the front landing gear accessible from the outside of the plane at any time!
It was by far the best technical document I have ever read, of any type, ever by at least a factor of ten. It was so good I read it like a novel. Twice. The security design was amazing. The PKI was amazing. The patch management was amazing. The network design was amazing. The documentation was amazing. My estimate was the the document alone would have cost multiple millions of dollars to write, not including any of the engineering work that went into the solution itself.
Boeing's engineers thought of everything. EVERYTHING. This scenario was catered for:
- The plane is rented, not owned.
- The IT department is outsourced.
- Aircraft maintenance is outsourced.
- The plane is currently on the ground in a country that is hostile.
- A critical update has been released, without which the plane is unsafe to fly.
This is one of the scenarios that is literally spelled out, in plain English, and you're left completely certain that the update will be safe and secure despite all of that.
The security is just nuts. Everything uses explicit, hardcoded whitelists. TLS is bidirectional (clients are verified by the servers too). Patches must be quadruple signed by Boing, the parts manufacturer, the FAA, and the airline at a minimum to be acceptable. There are physical connection breakers and PIN codes on top of that. There are two nested VPNs on top of the already encrypted WiFi. It just goes on and on.
No part of it left me thinking they could have done better. I've used that document as a template for my own work, and it's the better for it.
Since then, I've insisted on flying 787s whenever possible, because I'm certain that the engineering effort that has gone into those things is about as good as humanly possible.
- profile53 7y agoThat sounds like a fascinating read -- do you happen to have a link to the document (or even a title for it) if it's publicly available? A preliminary Google search turned up nothing
- heliodor 7y ago> "No part of it left me thinking they could have done better." Do you have the knowledge required in order to judge that? > I've insisted on flying 787s whenever possible, because I'm certain that the engineering effort that has gone into those things is about as good as humanly possible. Have you compared it to the other Boeing airplanes? To Airbus airplanes? Bombardier? Embraer? The new Mitsubishi airplane?
- brokenmachine 7y agoReading that just makes me think about how "wild west" self-driving cars seem to be, and most people seem to think that's acceptable. We have Teslas that don't have anywhere near this kind of security or redundancy "autopiloting" themselves right now on highways. People seem to be ok with that because it's a car and not a plane. But the way I see it, there's thousands of those cars on the roads, and a software bug across the fleet could cause just as much damage as a plane crash.
- nexuist 7y ago>We have Teslas that don't have anywhere near this kind of security or redundancy "autopiloting" themselves right now on highways. Not just Teslas, modern vehicles in general. I would say that in terms of security Tesla is probably doing a more bang-up job than the other automakers; it was only a few years ago that Charlie Miller and Chris Valasek remotely killed a Grand Cherokee on the highway.
- skgoa 7y agoAs an automotive security engineer, I have to interject. Miller and Valasek hacked into a car that was very far removed from what we consider modern automotive electronics. Any truly modern car will have decoupled networks with firewalls in-between. It will have intrusion detection systems, secure boot, signed code, encrypted memory, will communicate critical information via TLS etc. The Jeep hack (as well as their Toyota and Ford hacks) was exptremely important, because it put public pressure on the less technologically capable OEMs to get with the times and implement a (somewhat) secure electronics architecture. As someone who shares the road with those shitty cars I'm thankful for that. But even at the time of the hack, there were many OEMs whose cars were not anywhere close to that vulnerable and the industry hasn't stood still since then. And since you mention Tesla, I also have to point out that they are one of the worst at security. E.g. they have an RJ45 port behind the dash that you can just plug into. It used to be that this gave you complete access to everything, but people abused it. So Tesla made it a little bit harder, though not impossible, to get into their system. Tesla also has a lot of bugs in their smartphone integration that allow "fun" exploits like remote unlocking.
- forumSliding 7y agoYour account is 8 months old, with only a handful of comments made in the past month. I'm not saying that it's certain that you're a suspicious commenter, but I can say I'm uncertain about enough to raise an eyebrow at this particular comment, granted that it's just absolutely gushing praise and amounts to little more than hearsay. It's nice that you read and enjoyed a technical document, but we're talking about a really big company with a lot riding on this plane, deep pockets, and a motive to throw some weight behind tactics to reassure the public and engender trust, especially among geeks where much shade has been thrown at the technical aspects of MCAS and the way Boeing handled the classification of the 737 MAX as just a newer, better 737. The 787 is its flagship commercial product, so it's probably pretty good, but it's kinda weird to see new accounts acting like this. I'd have preferred that there be someone with more HN user history backing this praise.
- gthtjtkt 7y ago> My estimate was the the document alone would have cost multiple millions of dollars to write, not including any of the engineering work that went into the solution itself. Well... some completely random stranger with no credibility and no supporting documentation said it on the internet, so it must be true. The 787 is the greatest technical achievement of mankind, bar none!
- scrollaway 7y ago> My estimate was the the document alone would have cost multiple millions of dollars to write I get that technical documentation can be incredibly good, but even picturing the most thorough and well-written documentation book I can, what could possibly make it worth "millions of dollars to write" when writing an actual book hardly can top $100k even by going all out on expenses?
- hermitdev 7y agoI imagine most of the cost in the OP isnt the physical writing of the documentation, but rather in the time gathering the documentation, interviewing the engineers and developers. Then on top of that, might need to employ separate engineers to review designs/code and verify that the information is correct and accurate. Effectively a design/implementation audit. If done truly independently, I can imagine this gets quite expensive very quickly. I'm sure the number of lines of code involved in a 787 is probably well into the 10s of millions. Then you've also need help of Electrical/Computer engineers, mechanical engineers, aerospace engineers and who knows what else. This isn't a simple matter of plopping a tech writer in front of a computer and "punch out the doc". I dont imagine the systems are simple enough that you have a single engineer or developer looking at the relevant systems. I can easily see a team of well more than 50 being needed to produce such documentation, and conclude the cost of production for such documentation being $1M USD to probably being way on the low end, maybe even by an order of magnitude or more.
- justinjlynn 7y agoDo you have a link to this document/set of documents? If they're what you indicate, I'd love to read them - they sound fascinating.
- microcolonel 7y agoYou could probably find them on Baidu 百科, if it's anything like it used to be. ;- )
- justinjlynn 7y agoI need to learn Mandarin and Simplified Chinese, at least.
- laythea 7y agoThen again, the more complicated something is 1) the easier it is to break 2) the more vulnerable it is, no matter what the designers think. It gets to a point where full testing cannot be done.
- croh 7y agoHmm looks like it is job of a single or 2 authors who were really in love with their jobs(most probably contractors). having seen interviews of different people from boeing, i dont believe they can do anything good unless there is money
- kaonashi 7y agoThey engineered a marketing system that allows Boeing to price discriminate, one which artificially makes the plane worse. That should tell you everything you need to know about what's happened to Boeing's engineering culture and who's running the company.