5 ms·
Not surprising. At Netflix, despite the already high salaries, the security engineers were paid a premium for their skills. The highest paid engineers at Netf
by jedberg 7y ago
Not surprising. At Netflix, despite the already high salaries, the security engineers were paid a premium for their skills. The highest paid engineers at Netflix were security engineers. They did stuff like invent entirely new security protocols[0][1].
[0] https://medium.com/netflix-techblog/message-security-layer-a-modern-take-on-securing-communication-f16964b79642 https://medium.com/netflix-techblog/message-security-layer-a...
[1] https://github.com/Netflix/msl https://github.com/Netflix/msl
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoHow do you know what everyone was paid? That’s definitely not the norm though - security engineers are typically classified the same as an SDE for payroll purposes, and tend to have less negotiating leverage than high level SDEs who build and ship products, except maybe some very rare exceptions. But most companies also don’t have their security engineers actually write shipping code. I think this article, like every security related article from bloomberg, is pretty much BS. Also, they use the example of CISO at a large company. CISOs aren’t actually security experts in the vast majority of companies. They’re usually business people or outright frauds, disappointingly. The people who hire and interview them have no way to validate them. The article makes a case for why CISOs are worth a lot, justifying the cost of a breach. The problem is that CISOs have virtually no impact on whether or not you get breached, and they usually bear no responsibility for it. It doesn’t matter who you pay how much - it isn’t going to affect the outcome much. Alex Stamos is one of the few that actually has any background in security at all, and look what good that did Yahoo and Facebook. Not much. The other problem is CISOs rarely get any actual authority over product, and when they try to flex, they just get pushed out. The ones who survive are simply master politicians who manage their messaging and their image. The real reason for this article, I suspect, which appears to be primarily sourced from a security recruiting firm, is that they take a cut of every position they fill. It’s very much in their best interest to pump up the value to justify their fees. Most security money is very poorly spent. I think part of the problem is that hackers are usually bad managers, and tend to be less interested in playing corporate politics. So the manager jobs go to someone else, who has to make decisions they don’t understand. The higher up you go, the more this gets amplified. For every breach you hear about, that company likely has a few competent security folks saying, “see, I told you...”
- Bhilai 7y agoAgreed on most points except in some cases where CISOs are actually people who rise up through the ranks within security and actually know their shit. But I concede that its not very common.
- tptacek 7y agoI don't know what they did at Microsoft, but this is just pants-are-shirts wrong for SFBA tech companies. I could tell you I know this from near-firsthand experience (getting offers, watching friends get offers, for both SDE and security roles, as well as doing technical recruiting work for our clients, who are almost all SFBA startups), but you're also responding to someone giving you firsthand knowledge at Netflix. The people telling you security talent commands a premium are not lying and they're not wrong. There is a general instinct people have to push back on "look at these high salaries" data points because, not to put too fine a point on it, they're not good negotiators and get second-tier offers. That includes a lot of people with truly extraordinary talent; negotiating skill and delivery skill are, of course, orthogonal. But even that is changing; all you have to do is keep your ear to the ground to know that the standard SFBA SDE salary is not the market clearing rate for (e.g.) software security.
- novok 7y agoSo what is the market clearing TC for security SDEs? A google staff level security eng vs a google staff level general eng for example?
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoGoogle does not differentiate those roles (like just about every company). Most companies have a “faux title” and a real title. The real title for security engineers is usually the same title as software engineers. I’m not saying that no company exists with security engineers in a separate pay ladder (because who knows), but I’ve personally never heard of one. It’s about as difficult to answer that as it is to answer what the market rate is for SDEs. They vary wildly. Like hundreds of thousands in variation. And even the same role at the same level varies wildly depending on negotiated initial offer and performance bonuses/discretionary equity grants. Facebook in particular gave out $1M in DE to their top performing SDEs, even at lower pay grades. Also, appsec tends to be distinct from IT security (who tend to be classified as IT/SRE/Ops or similar), and often outside of the CISO/CSO scope, but not always.
- ummonk 7y agoOn the other hand at Facebook security engineers are paid less than software engineers.