3 ms·
How is this more cheaply produced as a separate chip? If that's the case then AMD could exploit it. I thought the point was that producing this would be cheap
by kenjackson 16y ago
How is this more cheaply produced as a separate chip? If that's the case then AMD could exploit it. I thought the point was that producing this would be cheaper, passing on the cost savings to the consumer, while at the same time offering better perf than low-end GPUs.
Everything I've seen seems to indicate that this is true. Did I miss something?
- mistermann 16y agoNo, I think you are indeed correct.
- Retric 16y agoThe larger the chip the fewer chips you get from the same process. The larger the chip the higher risk a failure. The larger the number of transistors the lower your heat budget for the remaining chip. But, far more importantly, producing a 32nm graphics chip is more expensive (for now) than a 45nm chip using the same number of transistors. Intel has a huge process advantage and is often on the lookout for useful things to do with their huge transistor budget, but integrated graphics has huge downsides, most notably memory bandwidth issues.
- kenjackson 16y agoRegarding BW, the GPU now has access to onchip (L3) cache. Since low-end GPUs use shared memory anyways, this actually saves bandwidth to main memory, and also since it needn't go get main memory, also saves power (from the power hungry GPU). I get that you decrease yield, but w/o knowing the numbers, it's hard to really see if its much impact on the bottomline. I suspect its a bigger win than loss (not hard to speculate, since Intel apparently had made the same bet).
- Retric 16y ago8MB of Cache has far less value when dealing with modern 3D rendering than you might think. Granted, building HW to deal with HD Video decoding is a huge win from an energy use perspective, but 3D is a different beast that is not vary cache friendly. To give some idea of cache's relative value a GT110 is a 3 billion transistor chip with less than 1mb of cache. A QX9650 is a 0.82 billion transistor chip with 12MB of cache. PS: At a minimum it's a 1 - (1/1.2) = 17% loss but adding in bad chips it's probably closer to 25% until they start selling chips without video capabilities. Also, I am not saying it's a bad long term move, just that in the short term it's risky.