4 ms·
This thing is very much a marketing gimmick, but the idea is not horrible. A Toyota Camry is 4.9 meters long and 1.8 meters wide. That’s almost 9m2, if they c
by Retric 7y ago
This thing is very much a marketing gimmick, but the idea is not horrible.
A Toyota Camry is 4.9 meters long and 1.8 meters wide. That’s almost 9m2, if they can cover ~2/3 of that with panels you’re talking around 6m2. You don’t get to tilt the panels, but you can put them on the sides which makes up for it.
Space is limited so using 30+% efficient panels is reasonable. That’s 1.8+ kw in full sun which is about 5.4 miles of range per hour. These numbers are appropriate, but when you start talking 40+ miles extra range per day that’s not worthless.
Use fewer lower efficiency panels and 20 miles per day should be cheap. This is well below that.
- jcampbell1 7y agoIt makes more sense to put solar panels on a roof than in a garage, and even more sense to put them in a field where it is easier to install and maintain.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoThere are advantages to putting the energy source as close to the storage as possible. DC solar cells charging a DC battery, instead of a solar plant converting to AC for transmission, then converting back to DC to charge a battery. Line losses and conversion losses add up.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gumby 7y agoit's not like people haven't thought about this a lot over the years. I've worked in both industries (solar power and on the electrical engineering side of automotive) and have seen these calculations over and over. On space: the car may be that size but the roof is smaller. The car tends to get dirty, be in absurd orientations, etc. Plus don't you want to park in the shade if possible? Ever driven in a city? You're suggesting multi-junction cells which cost an order of magnitude more than mass production polysilicon cells. For a vehicle where they are trying to trim the BOM by pennies (e.g. resorting to 8-bit CPUs in the ECU). I mean, great, more power (ahem) to them, but I can't make the math work. It's like the BIPV roof that musk keeps promising for delivery by 2016 or sooner: people have been making them for years and year and yet somehow they don't get deployed. Why? Well physics and economic factors like labor to start, as well as safety (which is the killer issue for me) and, quite significantly, aesthetics, which a lot of people seem to care about (I don't). Having the idea, and even making them, is the easiest part of getting them deployed.
- clairity 7y agoBIPV = building-integrated photovoltaics (for those, like me, who haven't run into the acronym before) as for my 2¢, regardless of the technical merits, i'm all for more solar. it's earth's ultimate energy source. let's cut out the intermediaries, particularly the unrenewable ones. regarding economics, it may not make a lot of sense on a cost basis, but as others have noted, it may make sense from a value basis (i.e., higher profit margins).
- Retric 7y agoSo far as you say it’s never really worked out, but that does not mean things will stay that way. I suspect when a ~2,500$ option lets people keep the AC running when forced to park in the sun people will seriously consider it. And at that point we are talking about significant power over time. The use case is different, but Solar conversion kits are quite popular for RV’s even if it’s not enough power to run the engine.