3 ms·
I think the suggestion here involves comparing the developer experience for the two. (QT would clearly win on all of the user experience and runtime performanc
by hedora 7y ago
I think the suggestion here involves comparing the developer experience for the two. (QT would clearly win on all of the user experience and runtime performance metrics.)
If not for developer experience, why is electron ever used for anything?
- leadingthenet 7y agoBecause a vast number of mediocre JavaScript developers can suddenly easily port their mediocre web apps to the desktop, and because companies love the "only one codebase" idea. There's no technical merit to Electron.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoThe native desktop application has been replaced for all but the most complex and inertia-driven established behemoths. Was there technical merit in moving desktop applications to the browser in the first place throughout the 2000s? In most cases: no. All of the functionality of the web interfaces could have been written as more performant native desktop analogues, but it's 2019 now and starting on the web is the defacto default while making a desktop application is the exception.
- afiori 7y agoBeing mediocre has nothing to do with it. Also portability from a popular platform is a technical merit. That Qt is better on its own is also a merit, but not the only one.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoIf Qt would win on user experience, why isn't it doing so now? This list[1] is out-dated (spotify uses electron, for example). But after skimming it I don't recognize any big software applications that have an exceptional user experience. Some, like Google Earth and Calibre are abysmal at best. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Software_that_uses_Qt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Software_that_uses_Qt
- eredengrin 7y agoReally? I see quite a few pieces of well known and often recommended software on that list. Dolphin, KeePassXC, Krita, OBS, Telegram, VirtualBox, and wireshark for the more common ones. There's some less well known gems in the list as well, eg pcmanfm is one of the first things I install on any new system.