4 ms·
I always assumed it's peers as opposed to superiors. I.e. Your jury is not the king and queen but other commoners like you.
by ModernMech 7y ago
I always assumed it's peers as opposed to superiors. I.e. Your jury is not the king and queen but other commoners like you.
- srfilipek 7y agoA peer of the defendant? Because the defendant was a musician in this case.
- sarah180 7y agoThe standard of "substantial similarity" in copyright law depends not on how an expert would see things, but on how a reasonable average person would see things. Juries are not perfect, but a jury of random people is probably the most qualified way to determine the question "would average people see these two things as substantially the same." Leonard French—a YouTuber and actual copyright attorney—does a good job covering the legal standards and issues here: https://youtu.be/t-tsw6Z4eHc https://youtu.be/t-tsw6Z4eHc.
- srfilipek 7y ago> a jury of random people is probably the most qualified way to determine the question "would average people see these two things as substantially the same." A jury of random people can be confused and then convinced by lawyers. That's the way they like it, and that's the problem with jury selection - they chose people specifically because they are not knowledgeable.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoWhats better? Experts that can be purchased? Elected or appointed judges who owe favors to those who elected or appointed them?
- srfilipek 7y ago> Whats better? [...lots of straw-men...] To start: Not removing jurors simply because they're knowledgeable or have critical thinking skills.
- dbcurtis 7y ago> other commoners Ummmm..... the Magna Carta was not about protecting the commoners from the king. It was about protecting the peerage from the king. "Jury of peers" is a jury of other members of the peerage trying a peer. Commoners were not part of the program.