4 ms·
and now lets take a loot to the inaccuracies in the article > If octopuses of some species can be kept together in moderate numbers and in larger enclosures wi
by pvaldes 7y ago
and now lets take a loot to the inaccuracies in the article
> If octopuses of some species can be kept together in moderate numbers and in larger enclosures with significant enrichment, this might mitigate some, though not all, of the welfare problems.
"Octopuses must be smart as chimps so they must be treated the same".
Wrong, they are solitary animals. All of the species fished. They tolerate other sexes only in reproduction and females could ignore other females (nesting at a safe distance) when taking care of its own nest.
From a young octopus to be in the same enclosure as another octopus mean only two things: dinner or imminent and stressful risk of death. To suggest that this would put more emotion in its sad lifes is like suggesting to improve the life of a zebra putting a lion in the same enclosure to play.
> Such efforts are occurring despite the fact that octopus farming has the same environmental consequences as other types of carnivorous aquaculture.
Consequences that include for example more small fishes using the area as nursery and sanctuary because there are not trawls anymore in the area. Or most ship noise and human activity concentrated now in a single point of the coast. The author suggests that all consequences are bad for biodiversity but this is false. Some are bad and other positive. Biodiversity around tuna enclosures is surprisingly high for example.
> And, like other carnivorous aquaculture, octopus farming would increase, not alleviate, pressure on wild aquatic animals
Same product. Indistinguisable taste. Two different prices. What the people will buy?
Pressure will increase in the same way as having a cheap alternative of phone will made everybody buy only the model of my-phone encrusted with diamonds. Why to eat cheap and available sheep meat all the year, when you could sell your house and eat wild himalayan blue sheep meat (only in november) instead?
Nine of each 10 sea breams that you can eat in your restaurant are domesticated, and you can find gilthead sea bream all the months of the year now, in all restaurants, because this fact.
- pvaldes 7y agolets take a loot -> (ouch) lets take a looK.
- Faark 7y ago> Wrong, they are solitary animals. All of the species fished I don't see how this is an inaccuracy in the article. The part just before your quote says octopus farming will be either uneconomical or we'll have to put each of them into a tiny solitary confinement cell, far from being species-appropriate. The article then leaves some escape hatch to be less absolutist, that you apparently didn't like. I don't see much of a problem with a sentence like that... after all, trained wolf's are used to guard sheep's. That comes quite close to your example.
- pvaldes 7y agoThere is not a "welfare problem" when a solitary species is keeping isolated, well feed, protected from predators and left alone in clean water. In the wild the same animal would look actively for tiny crevices and small spaces under the rocks to hide all day. Their place can be adjusted to its size. Tiny animals can be very comfortable sitting in tiny cages with all their sides protected.