4 ms·
He wants to do it with Super Puma. Ahem, its maximum takeoff weight is 9 tons... There is a limited supply of Mi-26s in the world, and I bet nobody these days
by baybal2 7y ago
He wants to do it with Super Puma. Ahem, its maximum takeoff weight is 9 tons...
There is a limited supply of Mi-26s in the world, and I bet nobody these days will be eager to even lease theirs.
Why none out of those "new age" launch companies uses the simplest solution? Parachutes and solid fuel rockets for soft landing.
- Taniwha 7y agoa) because they launch out over the ocean b) because you can't turn a solid rocket off once you've landed c) and because of the rocket equation any added mass costs so much more, if they could afford the mass for solids for landing they could just add more liquid fuel and do the spacex thing, that would likely use less mass
- baybal2 7y agoa) rocket should have huge positive buoyancy b) you just have to size them right for the rocket mass and terminal velocity with a parachute c) definitely, but propulsive landing also does not come with fuel as the only mass penalty. You also have to add mass of heavy hydraulics and sensors into consideration.
- pjc50 7y agoThe SpaceX reason for doing barge landings rather than just fishing the rockets out of the sea is that salt water is very damaging to the rocket. Landing on the barge requires active directional control. Most of the Soyuz deceleration is done with parachutes, I'm not sure how that scales to a whole first stage.
- Taniwha 7y agoyes, exactly, salt water is VERY VERY bad Your main engines are gimballed for guidance, that mass cost is already paid
- baybal2 7y agoI hardly can imagine why. Their rockets are carbon fibre, aluminum-lithium, and steel alloys with such overkill corrosion rating that they should stand strong acids, not simple seawater. And mass cost of hydraulics for propulsive landing != hydraulics for regular gimbal steering. Those should be very different in their power and mass. Not only they have to steer the gimbal much faster and harder, but also aerodynamic elements on the rocket, fuel throttle, and those legs they land on.
- pjc50 7y agoThe expensive bit is all the electronics and turbomachinery in the engines.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dotancohen 7y agoHow does one throttle a solid fuel rocket? And what does the thrust profile look like in the seconds leading up to, and after, ground contact? If you are really interested, try doing suicide burns in Kerbal Space Program. KSP is great for disspelling "why don't they just" questions.
- baybal2 7y ago1. Calculate terminal velocity of an empty rocket on a parachute 2. Calculate thrust and fuel reserve of solid rockets to reduce the speed of the rocket stage just below the speed at which it can survive hitting the ground Such schemes were used in Soyuz for half a century, Zenith for 30 years, and other parachute landing system for tanks and other military hardware.
- deepnotderp 7y agoSo to clarify, you want them to haul up a solid booster that has enough thrust to slow the rocket down during reentry and then deploy parachutes? Just the fuel for retropropulsive landing is already a major blow to falcon heavy or 9's payload. How much of a payload hit do you think this will be?
- baybal2 7y agoNo, no, no, the order is reversed: balutte/supersonic chute > regular chutes > last second breaking impulse with solid fuel engines to slow down the stage just enough to withstand the landing. Just like the landing systems for airdropped military hardware.