5 ms·
It bothers me that the term “capitalism” is being overloaded to mean “patents and intellectual property”. Other than that, this is a fantastic read, and it sou
by sneak 7y ago
It bothers me that the term “capitalism” is being overloaded to mean “patents and intellectual property”.
Other than that, this is a fantastic read, and it sounds like they are doing great work.
- littlestymaar 7y agoCapitalism describes a social organization where some people (the capitalists) own the means of production whereas most people are working for them. And nowadays, the «means of productions» are mostly in the form of patents and intellectual property (as most companies almost never build anything themselves[1], and pay contractors to build stuff for them). [1] Apple don't build Mac, Mc Donald's don't operate most of its restaurants, car manufacturers merely attach together a bunch of spare pieces built by contractors, etc.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoYou describe a general oligarchy. The point is that capital is not defined as the property of the capitalists. There are virtually no pure "capitalists" in the sense that they only own capital and do no work around that capital. In developed countries there aren't even that many pure workers, because most workers own insurance policies, some "means of production" or even equity in a company or two. The problems which are often called "capitalism" are in my opinion more about a power disequilibrium causing exploitation, especially using capital as power to take capital away from poorer people or distributing the value gain in a way that is perceived as inequitable.
- littlestymaar 7y agoCapitalism is indeed a form of oligarchy, I don't think this is a controversial view. Oligarchies can be justified by different reasons: religion, lineage, etc. In the case of Capitalism, it's an oligarchy legitimated by the “merit” of the dominant, who were somehow chosen in the great market competition.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoThe point is that any form of oligarchy means redistribution of wealth from the powerless to the powerful. And capitalism is not about "merit" but about possession. Lots of "Capitalists" (by which I mean people who derive most of their income from capital investments rather than labor) have inherited much or most of their wealth. Merit is not a requirement. Enough property to exert power and therefore redistribute wealth however is.
- littlestymaar 7y ago“Merit” isn't a real thing, but it's the mythical value that's used as a moral justification of the current state of societies. Like virtue, honor or faith in other kind of oligarchies.
- wtdata 7y ago> Capitalism describes a social organization where some people (the capitalists) own the means of production whereas most people are working for them. This is not accurate. Capitalism describes a system where people are free to own means of production. A hypothetical system where everyone owns some means of production, would still be capitalism.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> A hypothetical system where everyone owns some means of production, would still be capitalism. No, it wouldn't, because it is marketable ownership of the means of production that defines capitalism; that is, it is the buying and selling, not the ownership alone, that is key (particularly, historically, the marketability of the means of production is a key factor distinguishing capitalism from feudalism, in which much of the means of production was owned but attached to entailments which the current owners were not free to alienate.) For a version of your example, if everyone owned a fixed, equal share of the means of production which was not marketable, that would be an implementation of socialism.
- wtdata 7y ago> No, it wouldn't, because it is marketable ownership I have to be sincere, I never saw this definition involving marketability anywhere, this is new for me. Perhaps it's really like you say, but that's not the definition I had, nor the one I see as the generally accepted one when checking up the definition of capitalism. > For a version of your example, if everyone owned a fixed But that is the thing, it isn't fixed. You are free to manage it, sell it, buy it, as you wish. That's why it's an hypothetical situation, where everyone would end up with a part voluntarily and not forced by the state.
- dllthomas 7y agoIf people are free to buy and sell, "everyone owns some" is a description of some states of the system, not the system itself.
- dragonwriter 7y ago
- faissaloo 7y agoI agree, I prefer to use the term 'modern capitalism' to refer to the current implementation.
- iamnotacrook 7y agoIf one wasn't attempting to make money from others, and expect the State's help in doing so, it would make no sense for IP to exist as a concept. It's like when people say "competition is good for innovation". HN (the hobbiest stuff featured here, not the venture capitalist stuff) is proof that people will always do stuff for the fun of it. Hobbiests aren't competing - they're cooperating. Cooperation is far better for innovation than competition as you're helping each other and sharing resources, not making it harder for others to work in a similar area.
- sneak 7y agoI don’t think I agree; hobbyists have rarely, if ever, made truly compelling end products. I don’t think hobbyists could have produced Uber in every city I visit, or the iPhone, or a usable desktop OS (not kernel - OS), or even the microprocessor.
- tareqak 7y agoTo be fair, I think the interviewee is using the word “capitalism” to mean what some in the US today proclaim to be capitalism. I don’t have any citations for what I’m about to say, but I’ve heard of some US politicians describe the United States as a defender of both democracy and capitalism: compare this rhetoric with how similar US politicians describe “socialism” and “communism”. As a result, I interpret the interviewee simply continuing to make that association as incorrect as it is.