3 ms·
Any sort of politics would ruin the fun for me. I don't know how you OSS people do it while maintaining sanity. Those types of arrangements always attract some
by dmix 7y ago
Any sort of politics would ruin the fun for me. I don't know how you OSS people do it while maintaining sanity. Those types of arrangements always attract some bad actors (intentional or not).
There needs to be a strong limited vision for any project and a conservative approach to not try to fix what's not broken.
Getting rid of s expressions without it being part of a more cohesive improvement (like better supporting a new type system or something) just for mainstream appeal seems like an odd choice to me.
- neilv 7y agoI'm familiar with a lot of other open source projects and people, and I can guess what you mean about the occasional unintentional or intentional bad actor. FWIW, IMHO, there are no bad actors (as I see it) in Racket. What I think just happened is a little growing pains, when a few new things happened all at once, and everyone (including in core) was caught off-guard by at least one surprise. I think it all arguably reduces to areas of communication to improve. I absolutely agree about the strong vision, and I think that such a vision probably mostly exists, in core, but that it's not yet been made really-super-clear to everyone else, nor has there then been a chance for everyone else to comment on and influence an unambiguous draft vision. Until everyone comes to shared understanding and agreement on the top-level requirements, I think an RFC process on features and tactics seems not only premature, but also perpetuates misconceptions/misalignments.