10 ms·
I agree with Musk and see lidar where ray tracing was decades ago. It was an expensive impractical "holy grail". A set of lidar sensors right now costs as muc
by m463 7y ago
I agree with Musk and see lidar where ray tracing was decades ago. It was an expensive impractical "holy grail".
A set of lidar sensors right now costs as much as a car.
Maybe at some point in the future one of these lidar startups will come out with an inexpensive (maybe solid-state) version to augment the current sensors. Or maybe by that time vision will have gotten much better.
- georgeburdell 7y agoThe cost of lidar is going to plummet due to exactly the end of your post. Several startups (SiLC, Aeva, etc.) are using silicon photonic integrated circuits. Several more early stage startups have either mems or phase array prototypes for completely solid state chips.
- kjksf 7y agoThe thing is, self driving wars will likely be over before economies of scale for production of lidars will happen. If non-lidar system doesn't work, then the cost of lidar, even at $10k, is irrelevant. If you can make non-lidar system work better than humans (i.e. with quality acceptable for regulators) before the cost of lidars drops down significantly, then lidars lose based on economics. And the cost of lidar won't drop significantly quickly. The next step-change in price would probably require mass production i.e. production of hundreds of thousands of units per year. Even if lidar robotaxis happen before non-lidar ones, initially they'll be made in tens of thosands of units per year, leaving a couple of years for non-lidar tech to catch up.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gauku 7y agoBlickfeld is working on solid-state LIDAR. From what I've heard from friends working there, their sensor is/will be available for under $1000 which is a huge cost reduction from the current price(LIDAR) == price(car) solutions
- gundmc 7y agoWaymo claimed to be able to produce lidar sensors for 10% of market price back in January of 2017 (estimated $7500/unit). If true, it'll be critical to their scaling and success. https://techcrunch.com/2019/03/06/waymo-to-start-selling-standalone-lidar-sensors/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/03/06/waymo-to-start-selling-sta...
- m463 7y agoThe waymo cars I've seen seem to have many units on each car.