3 ms·
From Lehrer's article: "Why do we overeat? This isn't just a problem on Thanksgiving, of course: More than a third of Americans are obese, which means that we e
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
From Lehrer's article: "Why do we overeat? This isn't just a problem on Thanksgiving, of course: More than a third of Americans are obese, which means that we eat way too much every day."
Regardless, Taubes wasn't pointing out that calorie counting fails on a once a year gorging incident, he was discussing a daily increase in intake. Calorie counting works pretty well for such things.
Time will tell, of course, but I'm betting that in the end he wins the calorie counting argument, and the idea of counting all calories as equal regardless of source won't last.
If that's all he is arguing, then he is doing nothing but pushing mainstream nutrition science. But if that were what he is doing, why mislead people about what calorie counting actually claims? Why not show the actual claims of calorie counting, and then show how they can be 10-20% off in some cases?
By the way, every single sports medicine textbook already does this.