5 ms·
This is likely an unpopular opinion and one with many downsides we need to be very alarmed about but I think we are going to find that if there is any solution
by munificent 7y ago
This is likely an unpopular opinion and one with many downsides we need to be very alarmed about but I think we are going to find that if there is any solution to this, the solution is going to involve a global government.
Climate change and water are Earth-scale problems. If we don't have an Earth-scale organization that has real power working to solve those problems, we're going to end up with a bunch of nations feverishly wasting even more of our dwindling resources to try to push the suffering onto each other.
Do you want countries building desalinization plants and planting forests, or do you want them accumulating missiles and building walls? Unless there is some organization with enough power to prevent countries from fighting each other, you're going to get the latter.
- analognoise 7y agoHolding hands and singing Kumbaya has never worked on even a country scale and rarely works on a city level, now you want to extrapolate that to the whole planet? Good luck. Signed, those of us who build missiles.
- AWildC182 7y agoThe one thing better than a good defense is not needing to use it. Signed, someone else in your industry.
- analognoise 7y agoHey, I don't want to use it either. But it's pretty obvious we need it.
- chr1 7y agoGlobal government won't help with that. There are many countries with ongoing conflicts, that would continue between the people even if the governments were gone, and then planetary government would either have to send large number of troops into iraq/afganistan style conflicts, or let them fight and form their own governments.
- inscionent 7y agoWar is a market solution. Good Luck. Signed, The new Right
- rsync 7y agoI disagree with your contention that water is an earth scale problem. In fact, as someone charged with building and maintaining not only my own water sources and infrastructure, but community water resources as well, I would put forth that water resources - and their responsible usage - are governed by very unique hyperlocal conditions. We all know that, for instance, the water resources and usage are different between New York City and the Colorado River Basin - and we wouldn't expect usage and sharing agreements between those two locales. But are you aware that similar scale differences in water resources and usage can exist within the same county ? Physics and economics make them just as impractical to share and manage. There may indeed be drivers of global governance - and I typically find them distasteful - but I don't think this is one of them.
- danharaj 7y agoThere's already international politics about water sources. For example, the Tigris and Euphrates are very important to multiple countries, starting with Turkey and flowing downstream. In the US, you could imagine pipelines bringing water from the East Coast westwards. That could transform water economics in much of the nation, maybe even save an aquifer or two.
- avip 7y agoOk, now go tell that to a Syrian, Bangladeshian, or Ethiopian.
- xboxnolifes 7y ago> are governed by very unique hyperlocal conditions Yes, and what happens when 1 area does not have available water, another does, and the area with water does not want to share?
- GrayTextIsTruth 7y ago> This is likely an unpopular opinion no, just an opinion of a unrealistic dreamer. why wouldn't the govt be more corruptable by money than the current? The real unpopular opinion: the solution is simply less people. we need less infra, not more, and the problem will sort itself out. By overvaluing life, we have forgotten the value of life. We're killing everything, even the human spirit. Local communities need to start fending for themselves and stop importing/exporting everything. "but who gets to decide who gets to live and die?". everybody does. that's life
- UncleMeat 7y agoThat would work well if you got to pick your community. But with state borders and inherited wealth the people who get fucked are the ones who were just born in the wrong spot.
- GrayTextIsTruth 7y ago> That would work well if... no "if". its worked for thousands of years. weak communities will die off. people will have something to live and fight for, humanity will get a renewed vigor, and the water crisis will fix itself. It in the interest of the wealthy for their local communities to survive so they can grow food.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI too enjoy the Mad Max movies.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- plutonorm 7y agoEmpathy, you should try it, it feels good.
- kiliantics 7y ago
- hanniabu 7y agoCorporations would love to lobby an infiltrate this group.
- kiliantics 7y agoYes, so the new world government would have to be based on an economic system that doesn't allow for the existence of massively powerful and wealthy corporations or individuals, unlike the currently dominant capitalist system.
- AndrewGaspar 7y ago> Unless there is some organization with enough power to prevent countries from fighting each other, you're going to get the latter. How do you think you get a world government? I guarantee you it's not without somebody using some missiles!