4 ms·
Don't fusion reactors have problems with vessel degradation from fast neutrons turning the reactors themselves into radioactive waste? LFTR is what fusion shou
by AtlasBarfed 7y ago
Don't fusion reactors have problems with vessel degradation from fast neutrons turning the reactors themselves into radioactive waste?
LFTR is what fusion should have been, and should have gotten equivalent funding. Plentiful fuel (thorium), can "burn" current nuclear waste as fuel, meltdown safe, etc etc etc. And they can scale down to pretty small sizes, per another commenter's "construction" vs "factory production" comment.
The only interesting fusion idea I've seen is antimatter catalyze fusion rockets for space travel.
Wind/Solar/Storage have won. This would be wasted money.
- travisoneill1 7y agoIf they have won why do they not power most of the grid?
- ben_w 7y agoInertia. If I remember right, if you look at how the distribution of new power sources rather than existing ones, more than half of new power is renewable.
- munk-a 7y agoWithin America, at least, there are still quite heavy subsidies to fossil fuels companies to keep them competitive and keep jobs local - their survival is partially due to some heavy market manipulation by the government.
- pfdietz 7y agoBecause renewables have improved on a timescale short compared to the design lifetime of typical generating equipment. This is an unusual situation in the power business, and it means much of the installed base is zombie tech, obsolete stuff that wouldn't be used if the cost weren't sunk.
- ben_w 7y ago> Don't fusion reactors have problems with vessel degradation from fast neutrons turning the reactors themselves into radioactive waste? Yea and no. More neutrons per joule of output, but the waste is short-lived and easier to manage. But also the neutron flux is so large that every atom will get knocked out of its lattice over the reactor lifetime, so the metallurgy is (I’m told by a metallurgist) complicated.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe most serious problem with fusion, though, is that coolant does not circulate through the reactor, but rather around it. This makes fusion reactors have much lower power density than fission reactors.
- Jedd 7y agoThe first steam engines had problems with leaking steam - this problem was solved, and then we had the industrial revolution. Identifying problems that don't happen to have current solutions, and then suggesting other people not spend their time or resources trying to solve them, sounds like you have an agenda.
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoFusion isn't even economically viable, and can't be allegedly made viable without multibillion dollar projects with high probability and history of boondoggle status? Come on. Steam engines clearly produced power at a huge economic benefit. LFTR also has this characteristic, and also needs vessel engineering to become profitable and usable. Fusion has dubious net power benefits, dubious profitability even with net-energy experimental status. And all of that is wasted funding, that should go into battery, solar, wind, electrical transmission, and other storage means, which are beating coal (thankfully) and will hopefully beat natural gas soon. At the rate renewables are dropping in price, fusion will NEVER CATCH UP. It's not even a matter of the old "twenty years" joke. It's not going to catch up. Ok, maybe in a hundred years when the main research curve on those has finally petered out. If we're still here.
- Jedd 7y agoYou seem intent to couch your armchair predictions as ineluctable. Sticking with the steam engine comparison it was 320 years ago that we had the first proper steam engine (arguably some variety existed ~2 millennia ago, but that'd just support my argument even more). It took 70 years, though, before we had a decent one (Watt's). And that was before anyone had worked out how to bore accurate holes in cast iron -- so even that was version was a bit clunky. In contrast it's less than a hundred that we've even just known about neutrons, and the complexity delta between boiling water and fusion reactors suggests that we (you) should not assume that if we haven't solved all the problems around them yet, then we never can or will. Statements like this: > Steam engines clearly produced power at a huge economic benefit. invite questions as to why we hadn't been doing this for thousands of years. Everything is clear in hindsight. > And all of that is wasted funding, that should go into battery, solar, wind, electrical transmission, and other storage means, which are beating coal (thankfully) and will hopefully beat natural gas soon. How society expends its resources isn't a consensus arrangement - sometimes very frustrating, other times it works out well. Fusion research has a huge positive benefit if / when we get it to work. It's also probably going to be very important for the initial extra-solar expeditions. Doubtless there'll be other, currently unknown, benefits that come out of fusion-related research.