4 ms·
And here in the states there's bans on collecting rainwater on state by state basis, despite the fact that there's good data that it doesn't matter to the macro
by monocasa 7y ago
And here in the states there's bans on collecting rainwater on state by state basis, despite the fact that there's good data that it doesn't matter to the macro hydro systems if people collect rainwater.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3948194/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3948194/
In South America it's even crazier. Bolivia was forced to privatize their water system as part of the neoliberal polices they needed to enact in order to get a world bank loan. That new company banned rainwater collection and has used heavily armed paramilitaries to enforce it.
- mrec 7y ago> despite the fact that there's good data that it doesn't matter to the macro hydro systems if people collect rainwater There's an interesting comment below suggesting that bans may be more about preventing mosquito breeding grounds than capturing water supply.
- monocasa 7y agoHere in CO at least it's 100% a water rights thing. They're afraid of downstream lack of water if everyone is collecting their runoff (and afraid that the smaller farmers won't need to buy as much if they're collecting their own).
- davidw 7y ago> Here in CO Spelling out places might be helpful in a forum that is global. To me, CO means * Colombia, the country. I don't know much about water rights, usage and distribution there. * Colorado, the US state. Certainly a place where water rights are a hot topic. * Central Oregon, where I live, where it is also very dry and water makes or breaks farm and ranch operations. * Province of Como, abbreviated CO on license plates in Italy. Water isn't quite so contested there as far as I know.
- monocasa 7y agoColorado
- jacobsenscott 7y agoColorado I think. We need to put our rain barrels behind the house so the g-man (government man) doesn't see it.
- AWildC182 7y agoIIRC they were made legal explicitly around 2016 and were never actually illegal in any meaningful way.
- monocasa 7y agoIt was explicitly illegal before that, and now you can only collect two barrels from your roof if you live in a rural area (I think you have to be on a well).
- AWildC182 7y agohttp://www.leg.state.co.us/clics/clics2016a/csl.nsf/fsbillcont3/E38A8DB3F0B7739887257F240063F8A2?Open&file=1005_signed.pdf http://www.leg.state.co.us/clics/clics2016a/csl.nsf/fsbillco... Nothing about wells or rural areas, just 1-4 family units max and 110 gallons https://source.colostate.edu/extension-offers-fact-sheet-on-how-to-harvest-rainwater-under-new-colorado-rules/ https://source.colostate.edu/extension-offers-fact-sheet-on-... Previously they were only "technically" illegal because as written, you had to prove they injured the water rights of others.
- monocasa 7y ago> Nothing about wells or rural areas, just 1-4 family units max and 110 gallons The part you're looking for is the part about the state engineer. I'm not sure if it's all settled, but the goal there is to ban it in places where they can make an argument that the grey water in the rain barrels and the rest of the water infrastructure might mix. That means that rural areas off of water infrastructure are the only safe ones long term. > Previously they were only "technically" illegal because as written, you had to prove they injured the water rights of others. There was case law that any collection infringed on the water rights of others, because otherwise the water would flow into aquifers and what not if you only had a third grade knowledge of the water cycle. You didn't have to find the specific person that was harmed. My MIL in rural JeffCo got in a zoning fight with county gov, and that was one of the things they successfully hit her with. It was enforced, my own family got hit with it.
- asteli 7y agoIIRC they aren't afraid of people collecting runoff from their roofs -- more like collecting all of the water that falls on their land/building artificial reservoirs while starving the downstream watershed...
- monocasa 7y agoBut the root is, that's not really a thing out here. The runoff from rain like that doesn't tend to make its way into the water system on that go through the water cycle. Out here it mainly evaporates and sublemates. The water that makes its way into aquifers and rivers is almost entirely glacier/snowpack melt.
- avip 7y agoThe reasoning behind rainwater collection ban is usually health and safety, not environmental impact. Most nations treat their water.
- monocasa 7y agoMost nations that treat their water also have the concept of grey water.
- gwright 7y agoI'm trying to understand what it means for a private company to "ban" something. My guess is that the government created a framework for a private company to operate as highly regulated utility with a monopoly on water distribution. If my guess is correct then it is really the government that is supporting that "ban" and I would guess (putting my cynical hat on) that there are some pretty cozy relationships between the owners/investors in the private company and the government. The private part doesn't sound crazy all by itself, but I think it is a challenge to create systems that prevent a private regulated utility from abusing its privileged position.