6 ms·
> Isn't the whole point of insurance the basic bet that I will need an expensive service so I will make small payments towards that possibility, against the ins
by arcticbull 7y ago
> Isn't the whole point of insurance the basic bet that I will need an expensive service so I will make small payments towards that possibility, against the insurer's bet that I will not need that service and will instead be able to keep those payments as a profit?
Nope, health insurance isn't insurance because literally everyone will need access to health care at some point in their lives. 100% of us will die of heart disease, cancer, trauma, etc. It's like if we had a 100% chance of houses burning down, we wouldn't call it fire insurance. It's not insurance because it's intended to be consumed, it's a communal pot.
Further, no matter what there will be more things wrong with us than resources to deal with it so the other goal besides efficient administration of a health system is rationing access to care.
No need to profit here, there's plenty of other ways to make money in the world.
All these "the ACA raised my premiums crap" is just that. You didn't have heath insurance before, you had a program that you thought was health insurance but would have absolutely bankrupted the average person if you ever needed to draw on it.
- Stronico 7y ago>All these "the ACA raised my premiums crap" is just that. You didn't have heath insurance before, you had a program that you thought was health insurance but would have absolutely bankrupted the average person if you ever needed to draw on it. Why do you say that with certainty? I had a low premium / high deductible plan that was a good fit for me at the time that was both simple and lived up to it's promises, something I have not encountered since.
- arcticbull 7y agoA high deductible plan would bankrupt the average person if they ever needed to draw on it. The average American can't come up with $500 let alone $5000 so for them the high-deductible plan (the only only the could afford) is as good as nothing at all. You're still going to be relying on medicaid. It's not a real health insurance plan because it doesn't cover the realities of every-day life. You're leveraging (literal) survivorship bias in defense of this plan. You could make the same exact case if you didn't have health coverage at all, and nothing happened to you (that it was a good fit for you and it was both simple and lived up to its promises).
- Stronico 7y agoBy your reasoning is there any circumstance where a high deductible plan, albeit paired with an HSA, could ever work for anyone, at any time? Because it worked quite nicely for me for quite some time.
- throwaway5752 7y agoYes, if we allowed people that could not pay for treatment to die? That's the rub, right? If 999 out 1000 people in your insurance make the right decision, but one person gets... emergent liver failure by Hep C or needs a lung transplant, then the system only works if it is ruthless and the cost for treatment is not socialized (Medicaid).
- zepto 7y agoWhat if Stronico could afford $5000 in an emergency, and could also afford to pay for the much smaller incidental treatments not covered? It is clearly false for you to claim Stronico didn’t have insurance. If something serious had happened they would have paid the $5000 and the rest would have been covered by their plan. I agree that this might not work for the average American, but that’s the only valid part of your claim.
- arcticbull 7y agoTo your point I was speaking of the average American and not necessarily the poster themselves. Their plan worked just as well as not having insurance because they didn't need to draw on it.
- zepto 7y agoThis is misleading. Their plan would also have worked had they needed to draw on it. The fact that they didn’t need to draw on it has no bearing on whether their plan would have worked for them.
- arcticbull 7y ago
- TomMarius 7y agoSeems like this system would motivate insurers to develop anti aging measures. Good.
- arcticbull 7y agoIt's more profitable to just deny cover than invest in risky strategies like life extension. This is what we see play out on the regular.
- TomMarius 7y agoNot in a mutual insurance system (obviously there is none large enough to do that kind of research yet).
- mattmcknight 7y ago"Nope, health insurance isn't insurance because literally everyone will need access to health care at some point in their lives." Do you then also not consider whole life insurance to be real insurance, because everyone dies?
- ceejayoz 7y agoEveryone dies, but not everyone who does so needs life insurance.
- photojosh 7y agoI have whole life insurance. It's for a fixed amount, which would pay off the house with a little extra so my family would be okay. And importantly: once you get to a certain age the premiums start going up significantly, and you can't get it past a certain age IIRC is 65 on my policy.