4 ms·
It's about percentages. The law says they can keep a _percentage_ of the premium. If they charge you $1000 maybe they're allowed to keep $100 of that as profit
by tialaramex 7y ago
It's about percentages.
The law says they can keep a _percentage_ of the premium. If they charge you $1000 maybe they're allowed to keep $100 of that as profit. If they charge $900 they only get $90. So, provide a "better" service and charge $1500 then they get to keep $150.
The law used to let them keep whatever they could make, so you'd be right, they could buy $400 of healthcare, charge $1000 for and they've made $600 profit. But the percentage rules mean they'd be told to give you $560 back, they'd only be able to keep $40 in profit. So hence as the article says they choose to spend more so they make more money.
- zip1234 7y agoAmazing how good people are at finding loopholes in government regulations.
- grepthisab 7y agoNot a loophole,it was specifically written into the ACA to ensure insurance companies spend money on benefits rather than just pocketing everything. Of course, it also has the effect of making the market hard to enter. See, e.g., Oscar
- makomk 7y agoIt's worse than that. The ACA limits the percentage of their premium that can be used for all non-medical costs - including the insurers' profits, yes, but also including administrative costs like paying people to investigate potentially fraudulent claims. If they put resources into (say) catching that one guy who was fradulently billing them for workout advice at inflated rates[1], not only does it shrink the pool of money they're allowed to keep as profit, the cost of the investigation comes out of that pool and eats directly into their profits. The Affordable Care Act effectively penalizes insurers for rooting out false or inflated bills. [1] https://www.propublica.org/article/health-insurers-make-it-easy-for-scammers-to-steal-millions-who-pays-you https://www.propublica.org/article/health-insurers-make-it-e...