5 ms·
It is a lot more complex than you make it seem. Your position can be rephrased as "It is better to let refugees drown in the Mediterranean than think Europe mi
by unethical_ban 7y ago
It is a lot more complex than you make it seem.
Your position can be rephrased as "It is better to let refugees drown in the Mediterranean than think Europe might welcome more of them." I agree - it is likely over the long term that the more dangerous and hopeless the journey, the fewer might attempt it.
So now, we pit the "moral responsibility" to Europe to minimize population growth via immigration vs. the moral responsibility to save the lives of those in your backyard who have risked it to get there.
OR the EU could make/force an agreement that Libya/Algeria/Morocco take back migrants recovered in the Mediterranean.
- orbifold 7y agoIt certainly didn’t help that the US, France, Italy and the UK deliberately destabilized some of these countries (Libya in particular)
- wtdata 7y agoThis is the new version of Western Exceptionalism: Everything - bad - that happens in the world, is always fault of Europe or the US. The people that live in those countries, the warlords they support, the wars they fight, the human atrocities they commit, their ethnically motivated conflicts, are never their fault, we are supposed to treat them as infants when it comes to all the shortcomings of their actions.
- thefounder 7y agoTo keep it short, if you don't want migrants think twice before starting a war(i.e is it worth it? What after we win?) or just stop pretending you care about human rights(i.e people dying of hunger, abuse etc) even if you are indirectly responsible. I agree with you that many countries had flawed leadership to begin with it's not really the case with many others(i.e much of the middle east). Removing the government of another country by military force and destroying the social and physical infrastructure is the direct reason for the current situation. Arming various extremist groups does not help either. As we know Al-Qaeda was armed and trained by the U.S in the first place. Why did US invade Iraq? We know it's for the oil now but at least it should have had the decency to provide security/safety transition to a democracy in exchange for their resources. Not to mention that US vets their leaders/administration. They are not infants but have little choice in the face of the world's most powerful country/countries.
- baud147258 7y agoRegarding Lybia, the Western intervention just finished Khadafi's regime, the social and physical infrastructure were already well damaged from the existing conflict; without intervention, the conflict would have dragged on like in Syria. But now since there's a new war, the Western intervention seemed to have changed nothing, just with a new set of leaders.
- thefounder 7y ago>> Western intervention seemed to have changed nothing, just with a new set of leaders. That's why I believe the world starts loosing its faith in the West. The latest interventions brought nothing good.
- keanzu 7y ago> Why did US invade Iraq? Why did Iraq invade Kuwait? Start a fight with a US ally and then complain when the US intervenes.
- gamblor956 7y agoWrong war. Iraq didn't invade Kuwait the second time around; we blamed him for arming terrorists and maintaining weapons in violation of the terms of the ceasefire ending the first Gulf War.
- thefounder 7y agoThe Iraq-Kuwait war was settled 20 years before the Iraq invasion. So to answer your question Iraq invaded Kuwait for the same reasons U.S invaded Iraq: oil. Thus the reason we have a U.S invasion of Iraq, not a U.S-Iraq war. The pretext of invasions were different though. Busch said it was because Saddam was evil and had weapons of mass destruction. Saddam was more decent in its allegations and said Kuwait was stealing Iraqi petroleum through slant drilling. Btw Saddam Hussein regime was "created" by the US and the UK...
- stunt 7y agoIt’s not Western Exceptionalism. It’s about being empathetic as a human being. Unfortunately some politicians are harming the way we feel about each other for the sake of their own game.
- wtdata 7y agoPlease explain how blaming Europe/US for all the problems non western countries face, is "empathy". Because it really looks like "ideology", not like "empathy".
- stunt 7y agoEU replacing patrol ships with Drones is not different than building a wall in the boarder. EU is already rejecting many refugees. It’s not like someone that makes it to the shore is going to stay without a good reason. That’s not just a good solution to this problem.
- wtdata 7y agoMy comment you were responding to, had absolutely nothing to do with drones. The comment was about perpetually blaming the EU/US for whatever bad happens in 3rd world countries.
- cameldrv 7y agoI'm sympathetic to your annoyance at reflexive anti-Americanism. We sure have had a bad string of making the same mistakes though over the past twenty years. The pattern is: There is a dictator that is oppressing his people, we feel bad about it and want them to be able to have democracy. We overthrow the dictator, and then things get complicated and we walk away, leaving the place in civil war and ruin. Often the problem is that the only reason it's a country at all is that some guy in London drew a line on a map a couple of hundred years ago, and the borders do not reflect ethnic or religious loyalties. In this post colonial situation, often the only thing holding the country together was the violence of the dictator. We then swoop in with fighter jets and maybe even ground troops, maybe stick around a while to run a few elections, but generally without the understanding of what's left of the power structure in the country. This is precisely what happened in Libya, and after Iraq and Afghanistan it's shameful that we just continue to do the same thing. Bomb Gaddafi and let the chips fall where they may, which turns out to be years long civil war. If you want to look for a relatively successful model of U.S. intervention, it's what we did in Yugoslavia. Just recognize that the country doesn't have enough holding it together to be a functioning democracy, break it up along ethnic lines, institute democracy in the statelets, and then let them all join the EU when they're ready.
- deogeo 7y ago> the borders do not reflect ethnic or religious loyalties. Wouldn't the diversity give them strength?
- dmix 7y agoPlenty of borders in Europe, Asia, and even Africa have mixed nationality and religions too and there isn’t constant violence and repression by the biggest tribe. There’s far more positive examples than not around the globe. I’m actually in favour in smaller nation states and redrawing lines as a solution to the failures of centralized mega states and old world borders, such as lack of representation and cultural differences which cause policy conflicts (the smaller stuff, not just violence which is atypical in most places). Plus smaller states = way more experimentation, which the US states were supposed to be with Federalism but has had that slowly taken away. But that’s another story which doesn’t help explain the contradictions of this common explanation used selectively in Africa.
- mrighele 7y agoItaly had no interest to destabilize Libya, in fact it had a good relationship with Gaddafi. It intervened only after US and France started, as a sort of damage control, since France was set to replace the Italian-friendly government with a France-friendly one. (I will add that US, France and Egypt are _still_ making a mess in Libya by providing weapons to the opposition to the UN-recognized government). In any case, I don't think it would change too much, since most of the migrants are not Libyans running away from the civil war.
- baud147258 7y agoRegarding France, I though our gov publicly supported the UN-recognized government, with the French equivalent of 'thoughts and prayers' and not much more. But from reading the news, it seems it's a little more complicated.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> OR the EU could make/force an agreement that Libya/Algeria/Morocco take back migrants recovered in the Mediterranean. There is also a third option, which is to send them somewhere else. There are a number of countries in Africa that are poor, but still aren't in the midst of any active war or genocide. If you're from a country that is, why not go there? The answer is that the real reason so many want to come to the EU isn't the humanitarian crisis at home, it's for the better money. But when that's their primary motivation, and they have the same alternative as anyone from any of the other countries they could live in, then their claim is no better than anyone else's. It's fair to not want to be in Libya right now, but when you have the option to move east, west or south, there is a lot less moral force in the argument that you have a right to move north.
- stunt 7y agoHave you seen photos from these countries? Everything is destroyed in some cities and they have lost everything they had Including family members. Some countries in the Middle East are already hosting as much as total EU is hosting and even more. They just don’t complain as much as some of our politicians do to get voted.
- thefounder 7y ago>> Everything is destroyed in some cities and they have lost everything they had Including family members. I think most of us agree that migrants traveling long and dangerous distances to Europe don't have much to loose back home. Now the question is if their lives are not in danger anymore why should Europe host them and pay them a better life ? Is this supposed to be a solution to world's poverty? As we've seen if support is provided or better said lack of counter-measures you may experience a continuous stream of migrants(i.e millions). Even if we want, we can't welcome everybody, I fear we can't coup even with the people who really need help, let alone the economic migrants. On the other side there is also the cultural issue. Millions of people change the landscape for sure and the natives don't want to compete with migrants(why would they?). UK is leaving EU because of european "migrants" so it's not something to ignore.
- thefounder 7y agoI think the point is to stop these people taking dangerous journeys not to send them to the bottom of the sea. It both moral and more efficient.
- unethical_ban 7y agoThey obviously aren't going to stop the moment EU declares a cease to rescue operations. It will need to taper off, which will mean death in the short term.
- thefounder 7y agoI think this really isn't the case. It's just that "rescue" has a different meaning. Instead to wait for migrants get into european waters and bring them on EU shores they use drones to alert neighbouring countries (i.e Libya) and stop them taking these dangerous journeys before getting in EU waters. Otherwise what use would the drones have? Watch and bet whether the migrants make it or not on EU shores?
- frandroid 7y agoThey're using the drones to conduct other patrolling duties, not to save migrants.
- thefounder 7y agoObviously they look for any illegal cargo but I believe now the migrants make the bulk of incidents. Isn't this supposed to detect migrants ships faster(i.e before they get into EU waters) ?